Important: This article is general information for education only. It is not investment or tax advice, does not recommend buying, holding or selling any security, fund or product; we are not SEBI-registered investment advisers. For a demand or notice on your own account, consider speaking to a chartered accountant or tax practitioner.


Every month your payslip shows income tax deducted at source. You assume it reaches the government. Usually it does. But when a start-up runs out of cash, an outsourcing firm goes into insolvency, or a payroll vendor fails, the TDS deducted from employees can be kept back and never deposited. Employees often discover this only at return-filing time, when the Annual Information Statement (AIS) or Form 26AS shows less TDS than their Form 16 and payslips. Some then receive a processing intimation demanding the “unpaid” tax, plus interest.

If this has happened to you, the law is on your side, but you have to use it. This guide explains the protection, the evidence that matters and the practical steps.

The core rule: you cannot be asked to pay twice

Section 401 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, titled “Bar against direct demand on assessee”, carries forward what section 205 of the 1961 Act said. Where tax is deductible at source, the taxpayer shall not be called upon to pay that tax himself to the extent it has already been deducted from his income. In plain terms, once your employer has actually withheld the tax, the department’s remedy for non-payment is against the employer, not you.

For older years governed by the 1961 Act, section 205 applies in the same way. The Central Board of Direct Taxes also issued an instruction on 1 June 2015 directing that demands should not be enforced against deductees where tax was deducted but not deposited. Through 2025 and 2026, several Income Tax Appellate Tribunal benches and a Bombay High Court bench have reaffirmed that a deductee is entitled to credit, and cannot face recovery, for tax actually deducted.

What happens to the employer

Under section 398 of the 2025 Act, a person who deducts tax but fails to pay it is treated as an assessee in default. The unpaid amount, with interest, becomes a charge on the person’s assets, and penalties and prosecution can follow. Section 391 separately deals with tax payable directly by the taxpayer where no deduction was made. That distinction is crucial: if tax was not deducted, you may have to pay it yourself; if it was deducted and simply not deposited, the burden shifts to the employer.

SituationWho owes the tax to the governmentYour action
TDS deducted and depositedSettled; credit shows in AIS/26ASClaim credit in your return as normal
TDS deducted but not depositedEmployer (assessee in default)Claim credit with evidence; contest any demand
TDS not deducted at all, or under-deductedYou, on the shortfallPay self-assessment or advance tax
TDS deposited against wrong PAN or quarterDeposited, but mis-reportedAsk employer to file a correction statement

The last row is the most common cause of mismatch and the easiest to fix, so rule it out first. A mistyped PAN or wrong quarter in the employer’s TDS statement looks identical to non-deposit on your screen.

A worked example

Rahul, a backend engineer, worked for a funded start-up that shut down after a year of delayed salaries. His gross salary for the year was ₹24 lakh, and his payslips show TDS of ₹30,000 a month, or ₹3,60,000 for the year. His Form 16 Part B also shows ₹3,60,000. When he opens AIS, only ₹1,20,000 appears against his PAN: the employer deposited TDS for four months and then stopped.

Suppose his final tax liability for the year is exactly ₹3,60,000. If he files claiming full credit, automated processing may allow only the ₹1,20,000 that appears in the records and raise a demand of ₹2,40,000, plus interest. If he instead pays ₹2,40,000 “to be safe”, he has paid that tax twice, once through salary deduction and once from his savings.

His evidence is strong: monthly payslips showing the deduction, bank statements showing net salary credits that match the payslips, and Form 16. With these, he can claim credit for the full ₹3,60,000 and contest any demand on the strength of section 401 (or section 205 for a pre-2026-27 year).

The evidence that wins these cases

Tribunals have looked for proof that tax was actually deducted. The strongest documents are:

  • Form 16 (or its 2025 Act equivalent) issued by the employer, especially if Part A carries details that later failed to match.
  • Monthly payslips showing gross pay, TDS and net pay.
  • Bank statements showing salary credits equal to net pay, proving the deducted amount was withheld.
  • Offer or appointment letter and any revision letters showing the salary structure.
  • Correspondence with HR or payroll about the missing TDS, including any admission of non-payment.
  • Public records of the employer’s insolvency or closure, where relevant.

Download payslips while you still have access to the employer’s HR portal. Former employees of collapsed companies often lose portal access overnight.

Step-by-step: what to do

  1. Compare three sources. Total TDS on payslips, Form 16, and AIS/26AS. Note month-wise gaps. Our guide on reconciling AIS, TIS and Form 16 walks through this.
  2. Write to the employer. Ask, by email, whether the TDS was deposited and request challan details, or a correction statement if the PAN or quarter was wrong. Keep the reply.
  3. Use the e-filing portal’s grievance facility to record that TDS was deducted but is not reflected, attaching your evidence.
  4. File your return honestly. Report the full salary. Discuss with a tax professional how to present the TDS claim and supporting note, since automated processing matches figures to the department’s records.
  5. If a demand is raised, respond on the portal disagreeing with it, citing section 401 (or section 205 for older years) and the 2015 CBDT instruction, and attach evidence. See our explainer on reading an income tax intimation.
  6. Seek rectification or appeal if the response is rejected. Tribunal rulings strongly favour deductees with proof of deduction.
  7. Watch for refund adjustments. A wrongly raised demand can be set off against a later refund. Respond promptly to any proposed adjustment.

Common mistakes

  • Paying the demand without contesting it. Recovering tax paid twice is harder than objecting at the start.
  • Under-reporting salary to make figures “match”. Report your real income; the remedy is credit for TDS, not hiding salary.
  • Assuming any shortfall is the employer’s problem. If tax was never deducted, for example in months with no salary paid, section 401 does not help; tax on that income is yours to pay.
  • Ignoring the issue because the amount is small. Unresolved demands accrue interest and can be adjusted against future refunds.
  • Losing the paper trail. Without payslips and bank records, proving deduction becomes difficult.

Unpaid salary is a separate fight

When a company stops depositing TDS, it has often stopped paying salaries, PF and other dues too. The tax protection only covers tax actually withheld. Arrears of salary, gratuity or PF need to be pursued separately, through labour authorities, EPFO, or as a claim in insolvency proceedings. Keep the two tracks separate in your mind: one is about not paying tax twice; the other is about recovering money you were never paid.

FAQ

Does section 401 apply to returns I am filing now for 2025-26?
Returns for financial year 2025-26 are governed by the Income-tax Act, 1961, where the identical protection sits in section 205. Section 401 of the 2025 Act applies from tax year 2026-27 onwards.

Will the department refund tax that my employer never deposited?
Tribunal rulings have allowed deductees credit for tax actually deducted, and some have allowed resulting refunds. Expect to support the claim with evidence and possibly an appeal; it is rarely automatic.

What if I never received Form 16?
Payslips plus bank statements showing net salary credits are strong evidence of deduction. Request Form 16 in writing as well; the employer is legally required to issue it.

Sources


Last reviewed: 11 November 2026. This article is general information, not tax or investment advice. Facts and law in individual cases differ; consult a qualified tax professional about any demand or notice.

Leave a Reply

Trending