Two agents on the same team both skip the mandatory closing statement on a third of their calls. Their quality scores look identical. One of them has never properly understood when the statement applies to transferred calls. The other knows exactly what to say and skips it because it adds twenty seconds and their handle time is being watched. Sending both to the same refresher session wastes the first agent’s time only slightly and the second agent’s time completely.
The distinction between a skill problem and a will problem is one of the most practical ideas in floor management, because almost every intervention a team leader or quality analyst has works for one and fails for the other.
The one question that separates them
Robert Mager and Peter Pipe, in their classic book on analysing performance problems, suggested a test that still works well: could the person do it correctly if their life depended on it? If yes, the gap is not about knowledge or ability. If no, it is.
On a contact centre floor, you can apply this test directly. Ask the agent to walk through the scenario where they made the error, or role-play it. If they handle it perfectly when asked, they can do it, so something else is stopping them on live calls. If they stumble, hesitate or describe the wrong process, the gap is skill or knowledge.
Signs pointing to skill
- The errors are consistent: the agent makes the same mistake every time the situation arises.
- The errors cluster around complex or rare call types, recent policy changes, or a system screen they seldom use.
- New joiners or people recently moved from another process show the pattern more.
- The agent asks for help often, or puts customers on hold while searching for answers.
- When the right method is explained, performance improves quickly.
Signs pointing to will
- The errors are inconsistent: the agent does it right on audited-looking calls, or early in the shift, and skips it later.
- The skipped steps are the ones that cost time or effort, such as documentation, verification or proper call wrap-up.
- Performance was good before and declined without any change in the process.
- The agent knows the rule and can explain it, but the behaviour does not follow.
- Other signals move together: rising late logins, longer breaks, lower engagement.
A will problem is not automatically a character problem. “Won’t” often has a perfectly rational cause from the agent’s point of view.
The third category people forget: the environment
Thomas Gilbert’s work on human performance argued that most performance problems come from the environment, meaning information, tools and incentives, rather than from the individual’s knowledge or motives. On a BPO floor, environmental causes frequently disguise themselves as will problems:
- Conflicting targets. If an agent is told to cut handle time and also to read a 40-second disclosure, and only handle time appears on the daily leader board, skipping the disclosure is a response to incentives.
- Tool friction. If the CRM takes a minute to save notes, documentation quality falls across the whole team, not because people do not care.
- Missing feedback. If an agent never hears the result of their audits for three weeks, they cannot connect the behaviour to the consequence.
- Punishing the right behaviour. If agents who escalate correctly get questioned for “not resolving”, they will stop escalating.
A quick check: if many agents share the same “will” problem, look at the environment first. Individual will problems are individual; system problems show up in groups.
Matching the response to the cause
Max Landsberg’s skill/will matrix, from The Tao of Coaching, gives a compact map. Low skill and low will: direct closely. Low skill but high will: guide, by teaching and practising. High skill but low will: excite, by finding out what is blocking motivation. High skill and high will: delegate and stretch.
Translated to the floor:
- For skill gaps: side-by-side call listening, short targeted refreshers, role-plays on the specific scenario, a buddy from the top quartile, job aids for rare cases. Measure improvement on that specific error over the next two or three weeks.
- For will gaps: a private, direct conversation. Name the behaviour with evidence, ask what is going on, and listen. The answer may be burnout, a personal issue, resentment over a missed promotion, or the belief that nobody checks. Set a clear expectation and a consequence, and follow through.
- For environmental causes: fix the target, the tool or the feedback loop. Coaching individuals here is unfair and ineffective.
Where performance improvement plans fit
A performance improvement plan makes most sense once skill gaps have been addressed with real support and the environment has been ruled out. A PIP for a pure skill gap, without training, is simply documenting someone’s failure. A PIP for a will gap is legitimate when expectations have been made clear and the behaviour continues.
A fair PIP names specific, measurable behaviours rather than vague traits, states the support that will be provided, sets a realistic period, and schedules check-ins with written notes. Company policy and, where relevant, employment law determine the formal steps, so HR should be involved early. The goal stated at the start should honestly be improvement, not exit; agents can tell the difference, and so can the rest of the team watching how it is handled.
The underlying discipline is diagnosis before prescription. The same quality score can come from three completely different causes, and the speed with which a team leader distinguishes them decides how much coaching time is spent well.
Written by the RP Strativa Team. Scenarios are illustrative.
Leave a Reply