In a well-known 1974 paper, the psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman described an experiment in which participants watched a wheel of fortune land on a number, rigged to stop at either 10 or 65, and were then asked to estimate the percentage of African countries in the United Nations. People who saw 10 gave a median estimate of 25%. People who saw 65 gave 45%. The wheel had nothing to do with the question, and everyone knew it. It still moved their answers.

That effect, called anchoring, is one of the most replicated findings in behavioural research, and it shows up wherever people have to estimate a value under uncertainty. A negotiation over price is exactly that situation.

What the anchor actually does

When neither side is certain what a deal is worth, the first concrete number becomes a reference point. Subsequent offers are judged relative to it. If a vendor opens at ₹60 lakh for an annual licence, a counter-offer of ₹45 lakh feels like a large concession from the buyer’s side, even if the vendor would have happily accepted ₹40 lakh. If the vendor had opened at ₹42 lakh, the whole negotiation would happen in a lower range.

The mechanism is not that people are fooled. It is that people adjust away from a starting point, and they typically stop adjusting too early. A later study by Gregory Northcraft and Margaret Neale found that even experienced estate agents’ valuations of the same house shifted depending on the listing price they were shown, while the agents themselves largely denied being influenced by it. Expertise reduces anchoring less than people expect.

Myth: whoever names a number first loses

There is a piece of sales folklore that says never to name a price first. The anchoring research suggests the opposite in many situations: when you have good information about the value of what is being negotiated, making the first offer tends to work in your favour, because you set the reference point.

The folklore has a grain of truth. If you know very little about the other side’s budget or alternatives, opening first risks anchoring yourself too low, leaving money on the table that the buyer would have given. The rule is not “never go first” but “go first when you are well informed, and gather information first when you are not”. In enterprise sales, that is one of the practical reasons discovery comes before pricing.

Myth: a more extreme anchor is always better

An anchor works when it is plausible. An opening offer far outside anything the other side considers reasonable can backfire: the buyer may conclude that you are not serious, or that you do not understand their situation, and walk away rather than counter. In business-to-business selling, where buyers compare vendors, check reference pricing with peers and involve procurement teams, an absurd anchor can also damage trust for the rest of the relationship.

The strongest anchors are ambitious but justified. A vendor that opens at ₹60 lakh and explains it in terms of the client’s own numbers, such as the cost of manual reconciliation the software removes or the revenue at risk from downtime, is anchoring on value rather than on a bare figure. The justification makes the number harder to dismiss.

Anchors are not only prices

Anything that frames the range of discussion can anchor:

  • Packaging. Showing a premium tier first makes the middle tier look modest. Many SaaS pricing pages are ordered with this in mind.
  • Scope. Presenting the full-scope solution before the phased option anchors the client on what complete success looks like.
  • Contract length. Opening with a three-year term makes a two-year compromise feel like a concession by the vendor.
  • Cost of the problem. If the conversation establishes that a problem costs the client ₹2 crore a year, a ₹50 lakh solution is judged against ₹2 crore, not against zero.

When the other side anchors first

Buyers anchor too. Procurement teams often open with a budget figure, a competitor’s quote or a demand for a large discount. The worst response is to start negotiating from their number, because each counter-offer then implicitly accepts it as the reference point.

Better responses tend to do one of three things. Re-anchor quickly on a different reference, such as the value case or the scope that was actually evaluated. Question the anchor’s basis: is the competitor quote for the same scope, support level and contract term? Or shift the discussion to a different dimension entirely, such as phasing, term or payment structure, rather than haggling on the single number they put down.

Preparation is the best defence. Negotiation teaching, notably Roger Fisher and William Ury’s Getting to Yes, stresses knowing your best alternative to a negotiated agreement (BATNA) before you start. If you have already decided your walk-away point and the reasons for it, an aggressive anchor from the other side is information about their tactics, not a new reality.

Where anchoring stops working

Anchoring is strongest when value is uncertain. It weakens as information improves. A commodity with public pricing, a renewal where the customer knows exactly what they paid last year, or a buyer who has collected five detailed quotes for the same scope all leave little room for an anchor to move the outcome. In those cases, the negotiation is decided more by alternatives and leverage than by who spoke first.

It also weakens over a long relationship. A vendor who uses inflated anchors repeatedly teaches customers to discount everything they say. Anchoring is a real force, but credibility is the thing that lets it work.

Written by the RP Strativa Team. Prices in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending