Field notes. Short version first: the best salesperson in the room is made sales manager, the best developer becomes engineering manager, the most reliable accountant becomes head of finance. Eighteen months later, the team is unhappy and the company has lost a top performer from the role where they were excellent. I have seen no organisation that avoids this by accident. It is the default result unless somebody works to prevent it.

Where the name comes from

Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hull published The Peter Principle in 1969, half as satire. The claim: in a hierarchy, people tend to rise to their level of incompetence. Someone good at job A is promoted to B. If good at B, promoted to C. They stop only when they land in a job they are not good at, and there they stay. Over time, the book said, every position tends to be held by someone unable to do it well.

It is an exaggeration, and I would not teach it as a law. But it contains something real. A later academic study of sales workers at a US firm (Benson, Li and Shue, published in 2019) found that the firm tended to promote its best sellers to manager, and that those promoted tended to be worse managers than others who might have been chosen. Single company, single industry, so do not generalise too far. Still, the pattern matches what most managers say they have seen.

Why it keeps happening

First, the promotion criterion is wrong. Past performance in the current job is the easiest thing to see, so it becomes the test for the next job. But managing people is a different skill set: planning other people’s work, giving feedback, handling conflict, making trade-offs between people. A great individual contributor may have none of these, and no reason to have developed them.

Second, the ladder has only one direction. In many Indian companies, the only way to earn more, get a better title or be taken seriously is to manage people. Specialists who prefer the craft are pushed up anyway, and some accept because the alternative is stagnating pay. In that sense the organisation is not promoting talent; it is paying a ransom.

Third, there is no way back. If the new manager struggles, reversing the promotion feels like a public demotion, so everyone waits and hopes. A weak manager can do damage for years in the meantime, mostly out of sight, in attrition and disengagement in the team.

My opinion on the standard fixes

Training after the promotion is better than nothing, and is what most companies do. But it is late. A two-day “new manager” programme will not change someone’s willingness to have uncomfortable conversations.

A better move is to test before promoting. Give the candidate an acting role, a project lead assignment or an intern to mentor for a quarter. Watch how they behave when they are responsible for someone else’s output. Ask the people they worked with, not only the boss. This costs nothing but a little time, and it tells you more than a rating.

The real fix is to build a dual career ladder. A senior specialist track (principal engineer, lead analyst, domain expert) with pay bands that genuinely overlap with the management track at the same level. If a principal engineer can earn what an engineering manager earns, the choice becomes about preference rather than money. I am firm on this: if the specialist bands stop two levels below the management ones, you do not have a dual ladder; you have a consolation prize.

Finally, make the move reversible without shame. Say at the start that the first six to twelve months of any new management role is a trial with a defined review, and that going back to the specialist track is an accepted outcome, with pay protected for a transition period. Some people will take it, privately relieved.

A small worked case

Illustrative: Deepika is the top-rated backend developer in an Ahmedabad fintech team of 14. She is offered the engineering manager role, with a jump from ₹26 lakh to ₹32 lakh. She says yes, mainly because she is told the next band for developers tops out at ₹29 lakh. Within a year, her team’s output slows, two juniors leave, and Deepika is working late fixing code herself, because that is where she feels competent.

Replay it with the fixes. The company has a principal engineer band reaching ₹34 lakh. Deepika spends a quarter as tech lead on one project with two junior colleagues. She learns she enjoys architecture and mentoring but dislikes hiring, budgeting and performance paperwork. She chooses the principal track at ₹30 lakh, still a raise of ₹4 lakh. The company keeps its best developer and still has a manager role to fill with someone who actually wants it.

Where I would hold back

Not every promotion to management is a mistake. Plenty of excellent doers make excellent managers, and the principle can become an excuse for never developing people. Some roles really do require the manager to be the best practitioner, as in small teams or technical leadership. The principle is a warning light, not a verdict. When the next promotion list lands on your desk, ask one plain question of each name: what evidence do we have that this person can do the next job, not the current one?

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending