When a marketing deck says “₹1 crore in sales” and the finance report for the same month says ₹70 lakh, nobody is necessarily lying. They are reporting different layers of the same money. Revenue and margin terms are layered like an onion, and each layer strips out something else. The cleanest way to understand them is to follow one order all the way down.
One pair of headphones, layer by layer
An online electronics seller lists wireless headphones at ₹1,000. A festive coupon knocks off ₹100, so the customer pays ₹900. For this illustration, assume the price is GST-inclusive at 18% (the actual rate depends on the product’s classification, so always check).
| Layer | Amount (₹) | What was removed |
|---|---|---|
| List value (often called GMV or gross sales) | 1,000.00 | Nothing |
| Amount charged to customer | 900.00 | Discount of 100 |
| Net revenue | 762.71 | GST of 137.29 collected for the government |
| Gross profit | 282.71 | Cost of the headphones themselves (480) |
| Contribution | 192.71 | Delivery 60, payment gateway fee 18, packaging 12 |
The GST figure comes from dividing the inclusive price by 1.18: ₹900 ÷ 1.18 is ₹762.71, and the remaining ₹137.29 is tax. A common error is to take 18% of ₹900 (₹162) instead, which overstates the tax and understates revenue.
Gross revenue: the headline number
Gross revenue, gross sales and GMV (gross merchandise value) are used loosely and not always consistently. In marketplaces, GMV usually means the total value of goods sold through the platform, sometimes at list price and sometimes at transaction price, often before returns and cancellations. It measures activity, not income. A marketplace that takes a 15% commission on ₹100 crore of GMV earns something closer to ₹15 crore of its own revenue.
Because the definition varies, the first question to ask about any “gross” figure is: before or after discounts, taxes, cancellations and returns? Two dashboards that disagree on sales are very often answering that question differently.
Net revenue: what the business can call its own
Net revenue removes everything the business collects but does not keep, or gives back. Typical deductions are discounts, indirect taxes such as GST, returns and refunds, and sometimes allowances like cashback the seller funds. In formal financial statements, how revenue is recognised is governed by accounting standards (Ind AS 115 in India, aligned with IFRS 15), which also decide questions such as whether a platform reports the full sale value or only its commission. Analysts do not need to master those rules, but they should know their finance team’s revenue figure follows them and a product dashboard may not.
Gross margin: is the product itself profitable?
Gross profit is net revenue minus cost of goods sold (COGS): the cost of the item, or for a service business, the direct cost of delivering the service. Gross margin expresses it as a percentage of net revenue. For our headphones, ₹282.71 ÷ ₹762.71 is about 37.1%.
Gross margin tells you whether the basic buy-and-sell (or make-and-sell) activity creates value. What counts as COGS varies by company: some include inbound freight and warehousing, some do not. Comparing gross margins across companies without checking this is a classic trap.
Contribution margin: does each extra order help?
Contribution margin goes one step further and removes every cost that rises with each additional order: last-mile delivery, payment gateway fees, packaging, per-order customer support, and sometimes marketing spent on that order. What remains is the amount each order contributes towards fixed costs like salaries, rent and technology. Here it is ₹192.71, or about 25.3% of net revenue.
This is the number that matters for growth decisions. A business with a positive gross margin but a negative contribution margin loses more money on every order it adds. Quick commerce and food delivery companies watch contribution per order very closely for exactly this reason.
Scaling up to a month, with returns
Now suppose the seller ships 10,000 such orders in a month and 800 come back (8%). Assume returned units go back into stock, so their product cost is recovered, but the customer is refunded and every cost of delivering and collecting them is lost, plus ₹50 of reverse logistics per return.
- Gross value at list price: ₹1 crore. Amount charged to customers: ₹90 lakh.
- Net revenue on the 9,200 kept orders: about ₹70.17 lakh.
- Gross profit: about ₹26.01 lakh, still a 37.1% gross margin.
- Contribution: about ₹16.61 lakh, or 23.7% of net revenue, lower than the single-order 25.3% because returns carry costs without revenue.
Notice that returns did not change gross margin at all in this setup, yet they cut contribution. Someone looking only at gross margin would miss that an 8% return rate costs real money. In categories like fashion, where return rates are often much higher, this gap can decide whether a category is worth selling at all.
Keeping the numbers straight
When you report any of these figures, label the layer explicitly, state the period and whether cancellations and returns are netted out, and agree the definitions with finance before the number goes to leadership. Most “why don’t these reports match?” escalations disappear once both sides write down which layer of the onion they are holding.
Written by the RP Strativa Team. Figures, prices and the seller in the examples are illustrative.
Leave a Reply