Pull up a chair, because this is one of those ideas that sounds obvious and then quietly changes how you handle every price discussion. The idea is BATNA: the best alternative to a negotiated agreement. The term comes from the Harvard Negotiation Project, in the book Getting to Yes by Roger Fisher and William Ury. It simply means: if this deal does not happen, what is the best thing you can do instead?

Notice what it is not. It is not your target price, and it is not your “lowest acceptable” number pulled from a feeling in your stomach. It is a real course of action you could take on Monday morning. The strength of your position is decided by how good that alternative is, not by how well you speak.

Turning an alternative into a number

Let us take an invented services firm, Kaveri Systems, quoting ₹30 lakh for a year of support on a retailer’s order-management platform. Delivering it needs a team of four engineers, and the cost to Kaveri of doing so is ₹14 lakh for the year.

Now ask your junior-colleague question: what else would those four engineers do? Suppose there is another prospect, a ₹20 lakh deal costing ₹13 lakh to deliver, so ₹7 lakh of contribution. You think you have an 80% chance of winning it. The expected contribution from that alternative is 7 × 0.8 = ₹5.6 lakh.

So the lowest sensible price for the first deal is its delivery cost plus the contribution you give up: 14 + 5.6 = ₹19.6 lakh. Below that, you are better off with the alternative. That is your walk-away number, and it came from arithmetic rather than courage. Round it up to ₹20 lakh if you like, but write it down before the meeting.

If you have no alternative at all, say the team would sit idle, then the alternative is worth zero contribution, and the walk-away is just the delivery cost, ₹14 lakh. This is why a salesperson with a thin pipeline discounts so easily. It is not weakness of character; the maths really does push the walk-away number down.

Now do the same for the buyer

Half of the exercise is sitting in the other chair. The buyer, a retail chain, has options too. Perhaps a competitor quoted ₹26 lakh, but moving to them would cost ₹3 lakh in migration effort and retraining. Then the buyer’s real alternative is not ₹26 lakh; it is ₹29 lakh. Another option is to hire two people in-house, which might look like ₹22 lakh a year but comes with recruitment delay and key-person risk that the buyer’s CTO may or may not weigh heavily.

Put the two numbers side by side. Your floor is ₹19.6 lakh. The buyer’s ceiling, based on the competitor option, is around ₹29 lakh. Everything between is the zone of possible agreement, roughly ₹9.4 lakh wide. Any price in that range beats both sides’ alternatives; negotiation is the argument about where in the range the deal lands.

If the floor were above the ceiling, there is no zone, and no clever technique creates one. The honest move is to say so politely and go find a better-fitting customer. That is not failure; it is the system working.

Improving your alternative before the meeting

This part is underused. You cannot easily change what the customer is willing to pay, but you can often improve your own BATNA in the weeks before a hard conversation. Move the ₹20 lakh prospect from 80% to a signed letter of intent and the walk-away number jumps. Line up a second customer for the same team. Make your own pipeline less dependent on this one logo.

The buyer’s BATNA can be changed too, and not only in your favour. Questions such as “what happens to your Q3 launch if the vendor change slips?” help the buyer see that their alternative is costlier than the sticker price suggests. That is not manipulation if the cost is real. It is making the buyer’s own comparison complete.

Where this goes wrong

  • Fantasy alternatives. “We could always sell to someone else” is not a BATNA unless you can name the someone and estimate the odds. An imaginary alternative makes you overconfident and you lose deals you should have kept.
  • Ignoring non-price terms. Payment in 30 days versus 90 days, a longer term, a reference letter and a logo on your website all have monetary value. A deal at a slightly lower price with 15-day payment can beat a higher price paid after 120 days.
  • Revealing your number. Your walk-away is for you. Quote it to the buyer and the best possible outcome becomes exactly that figure.

Also, a BATNA is not a threat. Saying “I will go elsewhere” as a bluff, when you will not, damages trust the day it is called. Knowing you can walk is quiet. It shows up as calm, as a willingness to ask for the buyer’s reasoning, and as no urgency to fill silence.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending