The belief goes like this: it is the company’s policy, so the company can write whatever it likes about what happens when someone resigns. Put in a clause that resigning employees forfeit earned variable pay and accrued leave encashment, and the matter is closed. This is a comfortable belief for the HR team that drafts the clause. It is also the kind of clause that gets reviewed badly when it reaches a labour officer or a court.
The problem is not that every forfeiture is illegal. It is that the clause lumps together money of very different character. Pull it apart.
Money that is already earned
Salary for days worked is earned. Under the Code on Wages, 2019, an employee whose service ends, whether by resignation, dismissal or retrenchment, must be paid wages within two working days of the date of ending. A company cannot hold that back as a penalty for leaving. Deductions from wages are also limited to those the law permits, such as recovery of advances, and a catch-all “forfeiture on resignation” is not among them.
Gratuity has its own protection. Under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (and the Social Security Code which carries it forward), gratuity can be forfeited only on narrow grounds, such as termination for wilful damage to property, or for violence, or for an act of moral turpitude in the course of employment. Resignation is not one of them. A policy that said otherwise would not survive.
Leave encashment: depends on what the leave is
Leave comes in different kinds, and the answer differs. Casual and sick leave are usually not encashable under most company policies, and nothing forces them to be. Earned (privilege) leave is different: the Labour Codes and earlier state and central laws treat unavailed earned leave as something a worker is entitled to at exit, in specified circumstances, either by carrying forward or by being paid for. The OSH Code, for example, contains a provision that a worker who leaves service must be paid for earned leave due. Whether it applies to your staff depends on which Code provisions are in force for your establishment, whether the employee is a “worker” or a managerial employee, and what the state rules say.
So for a software company’s managerial staff, encashment on exit may be contractual: yes if the policy says so, no if it does not. For a covered worker, a flat policy of forfeiting accrued earned leave is risky. The honest drafting is to say: “unavailed earned leave is encashed at exit as the law and this policy require”, and then to specify the formula, usually basic salary divided by 26 or 30 per day.
Variable pay: the contested middle
This is where it gets interesting, and where I will not pretend there is one rule. Variable pay can be one of three things:
- An earned, calculated amount for a finished period: quarterly sales commission on closed deals, a monthly incentive on achieved targets. The employee did the work and the formula produced a number.
- A discretionary annual bonus declared after year-end, which the policy says is payable only to those on rolls on the payout date.
- A retention-linked payment, such as a joining bonus or a deferred component, explicitly conditional on staying for a period.
The third is the easiest to defend, provided the condition was clearly agreed in writing beforehand and the amount is reasonable. The second is commonly accepted in practice, and well-drafted “on rolls on payout date” clauses are widely used, though their enforceability can be challenged if the plan has operated otherwise or the bonus is really deferred pay for work already done. The first is the weakest ground for forfeiture. If a salesperson closed a deal in January and the commission formula says she has earned it, withholding it because she resigned in February looks like withholding wages. Whether the amount counts as wages under the Code is a legal question that turns on the facts, and courts have not given a single answer. The safer course, and the fairer one, is to pay earned variable pay for completed periods, usually pro-rated.
A better version of the clause
What might you write instead? Something along these lines, in prose:
- Earned incentives for periods that have already closed are paid on the normal cycle or in the final settlement.
- Annual discretionary bonus is payable only to employees who are on the rolls and not serving notice on the declared date, with the plan stating this on the first page.
- Retention payments are described separately, with their conditions and repayment terms, in the employee’s own agreement.
- Unavailed earned leave is dealt with according to the law and a stated formula; other leave lapses.
- Anything that is forfeited for misconduct goes through the disciplinary process, not through a resignation trigger.
The last point matters. If the intention is to deter employees who leave under a cloud, such as taking a client list, the right instrument is a proper clause about misconduct and confidentiality, applied after a fair inquiry. A blunt resignation penalty hits the honest employee and misses the dishonest one.
There is a practical angle too. Employees read these policies carefully at the moment they decide to leave. A harsh clause tells your remaining staff what the company thinks of people who go, and shows up in reviews on the employer rating sites. And it does little to keep anyone who has already decided.
Because the rules differ by employee category, state and the status of the Codes in your establishment, have a labour lawyer read any such clause before you issue it. A short consultation is cheap next to a claim before the labour authority.
Leave a Reply