Two phrases get used as if they meant the same thing in training rooms: “show empathy” and “show sympathy”. They are different behaviours, and on a customer call one of them works far better than the other. I will argue for empathy, with one exception.

Same call, two replies

A customer, Mr Nambiar, calls an airline about a cancelled flight. He was travelling to Kochi for his father’s health check-up and has now missed his appointment slot. He says all this quickly, voice tight.

Reply one, sympathy: “Oh sir, I am so sorry to hear that. That is very sad. We feel terrible about it.”

Reply two, empathy: “You were going for your father’s check-up and the cancellation has pushed that out. That is a real problem, not just a ticket issue. Let me first see what the earliest option to Kochi is today.”

Both are polite. But the first stays at the level of feeling and offers nothing for the man to hold on to. It is also about the agent: “we feel”. The second proves the agent heard the particular situation, names its weight and moves towards a fix. That difference is the whole topic.

The definitions, kept simple

Sympathy is feeling sorry for someone. It acknowledges that they are suffering, from a slight distance. Empathy is understanding what the person is going through from their side, and showing that you do. The first expresses concern. The second demonstrates comprehension. In a service call, comprehension is what customers can verify, because you repeated their specifics back correctly.

Why sympathy often fails on calls

Customers usually do not ring you to be consoled. They ring to have something fixed. Sympathy without action sounds like delay. Scripted sympathy is worse: when the same “I understand your frustration” opens every call, customers recognise the formula within seconds, and many hear it as dismissive. This is a common complaint about call centres in every country.

There is another risk. Heavy sympathy can raise the emotional temperature rather than lower it. Telling an angry customer “that must be so awful for you” invites more telling of how awful it was. A short acknowledgement and a move to solving usually calms people faster.

The engine underneath: active listening

You cannot fake empathy without listening. Active listening is listening to understand and then proving it. Practically it has a few parts:

  • Do not interrupt, even when you know where the sentence is going.
  • Note the facts and also the stakes: the father’s appointment mattered more than the seat number.
  • Reflect back in your own words, briefly, and check: “So the flight was cancelled this morning and you have not been offered anything yet, is that right?”
  • Ask one good question rather than three poor ones.
  • Keep your voice steady and your pace a little slower than the customer’s, if they are upset.

On a voice call, small acknowledgements such as “I see” and “okay” show you are present, but overdo them and they sound automatic. Silence of a second or two while you look something up is fine if you say what you are doing.

Where I would still choose sympathy

There are moments when no solution exists and a plain expression of sorrow is the correct thing. A caller reporting the death of an account holder to a bank or insurer, for example. Rushing to “the process for claims is as follows” would be cold. Say you are sorry, slowly and once, then explain the steps gently. Sympathy has a place when the loss cannot be repaired.

Writing it down: chat and email

In text there is no tone of voice, so specifics carry everything. “We apologise for the inconvenience” appears in thousands of emails and means nothing. “Your parcel was meant to arrive on Tuesday and is now stuck at the Hyderabad hub, so I have raised a priority trace; you will get an update by 6 pm today” shows both understanding and ownership. Include the time frame, because a promise with a time is the written form of empathy.

Can it be taught?

Partly. Whether someone naturally feels with others varies, but the visible behaviours, reflecting the situation, naming the impact, moving to action, are skills that practice with recorded calls improves. QA forms that reward the exact phrase “I understand” instead of the behaviour teach people to say the phrase, so the form itself can work against the goal.

In the Kochi call, the agent who reflected the father’s appointment rebooked Mr Nambiar on the next flight and arranged a refund of the extra transfer cost. The tone of his voice, I would guess, dropped about a notch at “that is a real problem”. It was the specifics that did it.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending