Buyers are wary of software they have not used, so most vendors give some way to try it. There are three common ways, and they are often confused because all are called “trials” in casual speech. They work differently, they attract different people, and they cost the seller different amounts. I will compare them and then say which I would choose for a typical business-to-business company in India. I may be wrong for your case; the reasoning is the useful part.

The three models

A free trial gives full or near-full access for a limited time, commonly 14 or 30 days, after which the user pays or loses access. A freemium plan gives a permanently free, limited version, and charges for more capacity or features. A paid pilot is a short, scoped project, at a fee, where a customer uses the product on a real problem with defined success criteria, and agrees in advance what happens if it succeeds.

What each costs you

Take illustrative numbers. A freemium product attracts 10,000 free sign-ups in a year. Each free account costs ₹30 a month in hosting and support overhead, so the free tier costs 10,000 × 30 × 12 = ₹36 lakh a year. If 2% convert to a paid plan of ₹60,000 a year, that is 200 customers and ₹1.2 crore of annual revenue. The economics work, on those assumptions. But notice they depend on a very small conversion rate and a very low cost per free user. Double the free-user cost, or halve the conversion, and the margin of safety shrinks quickly.

Now a paid pilot business selling larger deals. It runs 30 pilots a year at ₹1.5 lakh each, collecting ₹45 lakh. Half go on to annual contracts of ₹6 lakh, so 15 customers and ₹90 lakh of new annual revenue. The pilot fees nearly cover the delivery effort, and the people who start a pilot have already shown they will spend money and management time. The total is lower in headcount but the ratio of effort to outcome is easier to see.

These two businesses are not directly comparable: they sell at different price points to different buyers. That is the real point. The right model follows from the price, the buyer and the cost of serving one more trial user.

What each tells you about the buyer

A free sign-up tells you almost nothing. People sign up out of curiosity, to compare, to learn, or by accident. A user who connects their own data, invites colleagues and returns on four separate days tells you a great deal; and good freemium companies track exactly those behaviours, often called product-qualified leads. A pilot starts with a stronger signal, since someone agreed to pay and to allocate staff, but it can still fail if the pilot’s goal was vague.

Where each fails

  • Free trials fail when the product needs setup or data before it shows value. A 14-day clock that starts before the customer has finished loading their data expires with the user having seen nothing. Fix: start the clock at first value, or extend on request.
  • Freemium fails when the free tier is good enough forever, or when serving free users is costly. It also fails when the people using it are not the people who buy, so a pile of free users never turns into budget.
  • Paid pilots fail when success criteria are fuzzy. “See how it goes” is not a criterion. They also fail when the pilot is run by a junior who cannot trigger a purchase, so a great result still needs a fresh sales cycle.

Making a pilot end in a purchase

If you choose a pilot, write four things before it starts: the specific problem and the measurable result that counts as success, such as “reduce manual reconciliation time from six hours to two per week”; the people involved, including the person who decides; the dates; and what happens next if the result is met, preferably a pre-agreed price and a contract form. The last item is the one that turns a pilot into a deal. If the customer will not discuss it, the pilot is a free consulting exercise with a polite title.

My pick, and when it flips

For most Indian B2B software and services firms selling contracts of several lakh and above to mid-sized or large companies, I would use a paid or at least a cost-recovering pilot, with a free trial only for the lowest-priced self-serve plan. Reasons: your sales cycle already involves several people, so a pilot can bring them in early; a fee filters out the casually curious; and your delivery team’s time is your real constraint, which freemium does not protect.

I would flip to freemium if the product’s cost per extra user is close to zero, individuals can adopt it without approval, and usage spreads inside companies by itself, the way many collaboration and developer tools do. And I would flip to a plain free trial for a low-priced product bought by individuals or small firms with a credit card, where nobody will sit through a sales process for ₹5,000 a month.

A caution on free pilots: in India, buyers often ask for them, and refusing can feel like losing the deal. A middle path is a small fee credited against the first-year contract. The buyer feels no net cost if they proceed, and you still learn who is serious. Whichever you choose, measure it: sign-ups, activation, conversion and the effort spent per conversion. Without that, you will not know whether the generosity is paying for itself.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending