Farhan is a finance analyst at an illustrative consumer-goods company in Lucknow. Three years in, he is rated well, and he has started teaching himself data modelling in the evenings. An opening appears in the product analytics team, which sits two floors up, reports into a different vertical, and needs someone who understands margins and also can build dashboards. Farhan is a good match on paper. Eight weeks later he resigns, and four weeks after that he joins a competitor as a product analyst. Nobody at his old company ever said no to him. That is what makes the story instructive: the process simply never gave him a place to say yes.

Where Farhan’s move got stuck

Let me trace it. He saw the posting on the intranet and felt uneasy about applying, because the company’s unwritten rule was to tell your manager first. He told his manager, Gayatri, who is under pressure because the month-end close is coming and she has one other analyst. She did not forbid him. She said, “Let us discuss after the quarter closes.” The quarter closed; the posting was filled by an external candidate who had already been through interviews. Farhan updated his CV that weekend.

Nothing in this account involves a villain. Gayatri behaved the way most managers behave when their own team is thin. This is the central design problem of internal mobility: the manager who loses the person bears the whole cost, and the company gets the benefit. If the process relies on managers’ goodwill, it will quietly fail every time the work is busy, which is always.

The usual blockers, in rough order of how often they appear

  • Manager gatekeeping. Either an explicit “no move without my consent” rule or an implicit one.
  • Postings that go outside first or at the same time, so the internal candidate competes against a faster external process.
  • Pay rules that punish lateral moves. If a move to a new function means a “reset” of the increment or loss of a variable payout, nobody sensible applies.
  • Minimum tenure rules (say, 18 months in role) that were written to stop churn and now stop development.
  • A stigma attached to applying. The applicant is seen as disloyal, so people only look when they are already halfway out.

What a working process looks like

The fix is to change the incentives and the sequence, not to publish a motivational policy. A workable design has these features.

Internal postings open first, for a fixed period such as one or two weeks, before any external search starts. Eligible employees can apply without asking permission; the manager is informed at a defined point (typically when the candidate is shortlisted), not at the outset. That small change removes the stigma and the veto at once.

The current manager gets a say in timing, not in whether. A reasonable rule: the move happens within a transition window, perhaps four to eight weeks, to allow handover and a replacement. Within that window, the move is not blocked. Exceptions, for genuinely critical project phases, are decided by a senior person, not the manager alone, and are recorded.

Pay is set by the rules of the new role’s band, and the person keeps what they had earned (increment eligibility, tenure for leave and benefits) rather than starting from scratch. A move to a lower-paid function should be handled without a cut where the person’s pay is already within the new band.

And the losing manager has to be made whole in some way: backfill approved quickly, a recognition in their own scorecard for developing talent that moved up or across, and in some firms a short-term budget adjustment. Without something like this, managers will continue to hoard, and you cannot call that irrational.

Lighter ways to start

Not every company has the scale for a full marketplace. A small firm can begin with stretch assignments (a quarter spent on a project in another team, with the home manager’s agreement set in advance), job shadowing, or an annual career conversation that explicitly asks “which other roles here interest you?” and records the answer. Those conversations alone often surface a Farhan a year before he gets restless.

What to measure, and what not to over-read

Track the share of open roles filled internally, the time taken for internal moves versus external hires, and retention of people after an internal move compared with those who stayed put. Be modest about interpretation. A high internal fill rate is not automatically good: it may mean outside talent is being kept out, or that you are promoting people into roles they are not ready for. A low one is not automatically bad in a company that is growing quickly into new skills it does not have. The numbers prompt questions; they do not answer them.

Back to Farhan. What the company lost was not a particular analyst. It lost three years of knowledge about its own margins, which his new employer now enjoys, and it paid recruitment fees to fill both his old seat and the one he wanted. Spending a little on the sequence of a posting would have cost far less than that.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending