Ask ten HR professionals to name a change management model and you will hear three answers repeatedly: Lewin, Kotter, ADKAR. They are often presented as interchangeable. They are not. Each is good at a different job, and choosing wrongly produces a plan that looks tidy and does little.

To compare them fairly, I will use one scenario. A 3,000-person company is replacing annual ratings with quarterly check-ins and a new performance tool, effective from April. Managers are sceptical, employees are suspicious that it is a layoff tool, and the leadership team has said it is “a priority”.

Lewin: the simplest picture

Kurt Lewin, writing in the 1940s, described change as three phases: unfreeze, move, refreeze. Before anything new can stick, existing habits and beliefs have to be loosened. Then the change happens. Then the new way is anchored so people do not slip back.

Applied to the scenario: unfreezing means showing why annual ratings are failing (late feedback, disputes in the appraisal cycle, managers rating from memory of the last two months). Moving means training and launching the quarterly process. Refreezing means changing the forms, the bonus calendar and the manager scorecards so the old pattern cannot return.

Lewin’s strength is that you can explain it in a minute and it points at something people forget: the first and last phases. Its weakness is that it says little about how. It does not tell you who to involve, what to say, or what to do about a manager who nods in the town hall and ignores the process afterwards. Also, some critics find “refreezing” too static for organisations where change is continuous. That criticism has merit.

Kotter: a campaign plan for leaders

John Kotter’s eight steps, from his 1996 book on leading change, read like a programme plan: create urgency, build a guiding coalition, form a vision, communicate it, remove obstacles, create short-term wins, build on the gains, anchor the change in culture.

In our scenario Kotter would ask uncomfortable questions. Is there real urgency, or just an HR project? Is the coalition made of business leaders with credibility, or only the HR team? Where are the quick wins: perhaps one business unit that completes its first quarterly cycle on time and reports less rework? Which obstacles can leadership remove, such as an approval step that adds a week?

Its strength is that it treats change as something senior leaders must visibly drive. Its weakness is that it works at the level of the organisation. It says very little about why one particular manager, Anand in Chennai, is not completing check-ins. A neat eight-step plan can be fully executed while individuals remain unconvinced.

ADKAR: a diagnosis for each person

ADKAR comes from Jeff Hiatt and Prosci, the change management firm. It describes what one individual needs, in order: Awareness of why the change is needed, Desire to take part, Knowledge of how to change, Ability to do it in practice, and Reinforcement to keep it going.

The order matters, and it is diagnostic. Take Anand. He knows about the new process (awareness is fine). He has been trained (knowledge is fine). He still does not do the check-ins. So the gap is either desire or ability. A short conversation reveals it: he has fourteen reports and the tool needs forty minutes per person per quarter. That is ability, a capacity problem, and no further communication campaign will fix it. Reduce his span, simplify the form, or give him protected time.

Another manager, Divya, has the same behaviour for a different reason: she believes the old rating system rewarded her team fairly and sees the new one as a threat. That is desire, and the response is a different conversation altogether.

Side by side

ModelLevelBest question it helps you askBlind spot
LewinWhole organisation, broad stagesHave we prepared people to let go of the old way, and are we locking in the new one?Little practical detail
KotterOrganisation and leadershipDoes leadership behave as if this matters?Individual resistance
ADKARIndividual, aggregated to groupsWhere exactly is this person or team stuck?Leadership and political dynamics

Which one I would pick

My choice, which is an opinion: ADKAR for most HR-led changes, with Kotter’s questions borrowed for the leadership side. Policy and process changes in HR fail mostly at the individual level. Employees and managers do not fail to understand the memo; they fail to want it, or lack time or skill to follow it. ADKAR tells you which, so you can respond with training, with capacity, or with a hard conversation as the case may be.

Kotter becomes the better choice when the change is bigger than a process: a merger, a restructuring, a shift in business model. There, the problem is more often that leadership is not aligned, which no individual-level model can fix. And Lewin is useful mainly as a sketch for explaining the shape of change to a sponsor in two minutes.

One caution applies to all three. A model is a lens, not evidence. None of them has been proven to guarantee success, and each was built from observation and consulting practice more than from controlled experiments. Use them to ask better questions about your own organisation, and treat any step you cannot explain in your own words as a sign you have borrowed the model rather than understood it.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending