Two managers run similar teams. The first sets daily targets: 60 dials, 5 conversations, 2 follow-up emails per open deal, all logged in the CRM by 6 pm. The second sets one number, quarterly closed revenue, and otherwise leaves reps alone. The first is managing by activity. The second is managing by outcome. Each can point to people they have developed and to people they have lost, and each is partly right.
What activity management gets right
Activity is something the rep fully controls. Revenue depends on the customer’s budget, a competitor’s move, a regulatory delay, a bad quarter in the buyer’s industry. A rep who works hard and loses through no fault of their own is not helped by being told only “you missed”. Activity targets give clear daily direction, which matters most for people who are new and do not yet know what a good day looks like.
Activity numbers also arrive early. Revenue results come months after the work that caused them, so a manager waiting for outcomes learns about a problem very late. Seeing in week three that a rep has had two conversations when the team average is twenty lets you act before the quarter is gone. And where sales motions are well understood, such as a high-volume outbound team with a known conversion ladder, activity really does predict results.
Where it breaks
A measure that becomes a target tends to stop measuring what it did before; this is often called Goodhart’s law. Tell people to make 60 dials and you will get 60 dials, some of them hung up after two seconds. Ask for CRM updates by 6 pm and you will get updates that are accurate to the extent that it is convenient. The manager ends up reviewing a dashboard of effort that looks excellent while the pipeline is thin.
It also costs trust. Experienced reps, who know which three accounts matter this quarter, resent being told to log twenty activities that have nothing to do with those accounts. They leave, or they comply and stop thinking. For complex enterprise sales, where one well-prepared meeting with an economic buyer can matter more than a hundred calls, counting activity measures the wrong thing altogether.
What outcome management gets right
It respects the rep’s judgement and focuses everyone on what the company actually needs. It cannot be gamed in the same cheap way, since a signed contract is a signed contract. It suits experienced people and long, uncertain deal cycles, where the route to a result differs from rep to rep.
Where that breaks
Outcomes are noisy and slow. In a team of eight, one large deal that slips from March to April turns a good rep into a failure and another into a hero for reasons unrelated to skill. A manager who looks only at results cannot tell luck from performance, and cannot coach, because “close more” is not coaching. Outcome-only management can also tolerate bad behaviour: the rep who closes by over-discounting, over-promising or ignoring process gets praised until the damage arrives at renewal.
New joiners suffer most. Told only that they must deliver a number in six months, with no sense of what to do on Tuesday, some will freeze and some will thrash.
My lean
Judge by outcomes; manage with a small number of activities that are tightly linked to them. That is a lean, not a formula.
In practice, it means the review of a rep is about results and the quality of the pipeline, such as how many qualified opportunities exist, how old they are, and whether next steps are scheduled. Pipeline health sits between activity and revenue and is harder to fake. Then activity is used as a diagnostic, not a scoreboard: if outcomes are weak, look at the numbers beneath them to find where the gap is. If a rep with low activity is hitting target by cultivating a few large accounts, leave them alone. If a rep with high activity is missing, the activity is the wrong kind, and the conversation is about targeting and conversation quality, listening to recordings or joining calls, rather than about volume.
The balance should shift with the rep. For someone in their first three months, tighter activity guidance is kind, as long as it is explained and has an end date. For a rep with several years of strong results, it is mostly noise. For a team in a transactional, high-volume motion, activity targets can reasonably stay. For a team selling large, long deals, they probably should not.
I hold this opinion with some uncertainty. There are sales environments, particularly in very high-volume inside sales, where tight activity control has produced good results and where my preference for judgement might be too relaxed. Whichever way you lean, test it against your own data: if the reps who hit their activity numbers do not hit their revenue numbers, the activity you chose is not the right one, and the management system built on it needs to change.
Leave a Reply