A customer’s mobile order has not arrived. She starts a chat on the app, waits four minutes, and gets “please share your order number”. She shares it. The agent says it will take a day to check. Annoyed, she phones. The IVR asks for her order number again, then a person asks her to explain from the beginning. Still unresolved, she emails, and receives a reply that treats it as a brand new complaint. Three channels, three conversations, one problem. The company would proudly say it offers phone, chat and email. It is multichannel. It is not omnichannel, and the difference is the whole point of this piece.
Two definitions that actually separate
Multichannel means the customer can reach you through several channels. Each channel usually has its own team, its own tool, its own reporting and its own idea of who the customer is. The channels do not share what they know.
Omnichannel means the channels are connected around the customer. History, identity and context travel with the customer, so moving from chat to phone to email continues the same conversation. The unit of design is the customer’s journey, not the channel.
Marketing slides blur these, and vendors happily call any bundle of channels “omnichannel”. The test is practical: when a customer switches channel, does the next agent already know what happened?
What omnichannel needs underneath
The work is mostly plumbing, and it is harder than it looks.
- A single customer identity. The chat knows an app user ID, the phone knows a mobile number, the email knows an address. Something must connect them, with proper consent and verification, or the history does not join up.
- One shared record. A CRM or case system where every interaction is logged against the customer and the case, whatever the channel.
- Routing that sees context. A customer who chatted twice about the same order should reach someone who can fix it, not a fresh queue.
- Common reporting. Otherwise the chat team’s first-contact resolution looks excellent while the customer has quietly moved to the phone, where it counts as a new case.
- Agents who can handle more than one channel, or at least see the others’ notes. This changes hiring, training and quality forms.
Notice that none of this is about adding another channel such as WhatsApp. Adding a channel makes a company more multichannel. Connecting them makes it omnichannel. You can have excellent omnichannel with just two channels.
The measurement trap
Here is a consequence people miss. In a multichannel setup, each channel is measured on its own, so each can look healthy. Chat resolves 80% of its own conversations; phone resolves 75% of its own. Meanwhile many customers touched both. If you count resolution by customer issue instead of by channel interaction, the picture changes, and often gets worse. Omnichannel measurement often brings out figures nobody enjoys: repeat contacts across channels, total effort per issue, and time to final resolution. Leaders who want a flattering dashboard may not want to turn that on. I would argue they should, because the customer already knows the real number.
Taking a side
My view: for most businesses with real volume, omnichannel is the right direction, and a sensible first step is not a big platform purchase but fixing identity and case history across the two channels customers switch between most. Look at the data first. Which channel pairs do customers actually hop between? If it is mostly chat to phone, connect those two well before dreaming of a seamless everywhere.
Where is multichannel enough? When the business is small, issues are simple and short, and customers rarely need follow-up. A local clinic taking bookings by phone and WhatsApp does not need a unified customer platform; it needs to answer messages promptly. Also when the cost of integration exceeds the cost of the friction. A fix that costs ₹2 crore to save ₹30 lakh of repeat handling is not a good fix, however modern it sounds. Work out the arithmetic for your own case, using contact volume, repeat rate and cost per contact.
The strongest argument for omnichannel is not technology but respect. Asking a customer to repeat herself tells her the company does not remember her. The strongest argument against rushing is that a half-built version creates a false promise: customers are told “we’ll pass this to the team” when the handover does not exist.
The costs people underestimate
Data privacy is one. Joining records across channels means handling personal data more broadly, so consent, access control and retention rules (the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, in India, and whatever the client’s own regulations add) need to be part of the design, not a final review. Training is another: an agent used to voice must learn the rhythm of chat and the tone of written replies. Staffing is a third: chat and email behave differently from calls in forecasting, and a blended agent pool needs planning that handles several workloads at once. Finally, the BPO’s pricing: if the client buys seats per channel, a connected model changes the arithmetic of what they are paying for.
So when someone says their company is omnichannel, ask the dull question: if I chat today and call tomorrow, will the agent know? The answer is worth more than the channel list.
Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.
Leave a Reply