We will follow one invoice from the day the contract is signed to the day the cash lands, and stop at each step to see what is going on. The numbers are small and invented so that you can check every one of them yourself.

Day 0: the contract

A Bengaluru software company signs a one-year licence with a logistics firm for ₹60 lakh. The contract says: invoice on the start date, payment within 45 days of invoice. Those two sentences, the invoicing trigger and the payment term, decide the company’s cash position for the year more than the price discussion did, and they are often negotiated last and in a hurry.

Day 1: the invoice

The invoice carries GST on top. At 18%, the tax is ₹10.8 lakh, so the invoice total is ₹70.8 lakh. The customer is being asked for ₹70.8 lakh, but the supplier’s revenue is ₹60 lakh. The ₹10.8 lakh is held on behalf of the government and is owed to it whether or not the customer pays on time, subject to the GST rules on timing, which is one reason late payment hurts Indian suppliers harder than the headline figure suggests.

Invoice details matter more than people expect. A wrong GSTIN, a wrong purchase order number or a missing e-invoice reference gives the customer’s accounts-payable team a legitimate reason to bounce the invoice, and the 45-day clock often restarts from the corrected one.

Days 2 to 45: the customer’s process

Inside the customer, the invoice goes through three-way matching in many organisations: the purchase order, the proof that the goods or service were received, and the invoice must agree. Then it waits for the payment run, which may happen weekly, fortnightly or on a fixed date each month. If the invoice becomes approved on the 46th day and the next run is on the 52nd, the payment term in the contract has been missed through nobody’s malice.

The customer may also deduct tax at source (TDS) when paying, where the law applies to that payment. The cash that arrives is then lower than the invoice, and the supplier must claim credit for the deducted amount using the certificate or the statement the customer files. A supplier whose finance team does not reconcile TDS will see unexplained shortfalls for months.

One note for suppliers selling to small businesses or buying from them: under section 43B(h) of the Income-tax Act, in force from the 2023-24 financial year, a buyer who owes money to a registered micro or small enterprise and pays beyond the legal limit, 45 days with a written agreement and 15 without one, loses the tax deduction for that expense in that year. If your counterparty is such an enterprise, check the current rules with your tax adviser, because it changes who is willing to negotiate long terms.

Day 78: the cash arrives

The customer pays on day 78, not day 45. That is 33 days late, which is unremarkable. What did it cost? If the supplier’s cost of money is 11% a year, then funding ₹60 lakh for 78 days instead of 45 days costs 60 × 11% × 33 / 365, about ₹0.6 lakh. Funding it for the full 78 days costs about ₹1.41 lakh, compared with ₹0.81 lakh for the agreed 45. Fine, ₹60,000 is not a disaster. But multiply by two hundred invoices, and add the staff time spent chasing, and the real figure is something the finance head will care about.

Looking at all invoices together: DSO

A company with many such invoices needs a single number for how quickly it collects. Days sales outstanding, DSO, is the usual one. Divide receivables by sales over a period and multiply by the days in that period. If the company billed ₹3 crore in a quarter and has ₹1.4 crore outstanding at quarter end, DSO is 1.4 / 3 × 90 = 42 days.

Two cautions. Receivables here include GST while sales may not, so be consistent and compare like with like. And DSO is distorted by lumpy billing: a large invoice raised in the last week of a quarter inflates it without anyone being slow to pay. Many finance teams therefore also watch an ageing report, showing how much is 0 to 30 days overdue, 31 to 60, and so on, which tells you where the actual problem customers are.

Rerunning the year with a different billing plan

Suppose the company had instead invoiced ₹15 lakh at the start of each quarter, still on 45-day terms. Payments would arrive on days 45, 135, 225 and 315. The average day of receipt is 180 instead of 45. Holding the same ₹60 lakh for those extra 135 days on average costs 60 × 11% × 135 / 365, which is about ₹2.44 lakh a year.

Now see what this means for the common offer of a 5% discount for annual upfront payment. Five per cent of ₹60 lakh is ₹3 lakh. The cost of money saved is ₹2.44 lakh. At an 11% cost of money, the discount is worth slightly more than the early cash, so the supplier pays about ₹0.56 lakh for the privilege. At a 15% cost of money the saving would be about ₹3.33 lakh and the offer would be sensible. The right answer depends on the supplier’s own funding cost, and few sales teams check before offering it.

Annual upfront billing also changes risk. The customer who has paid for twelve months has a stronger reason to use the product; one who pays quarterly has more exits. And revenue is still recognised over the year, so the billing choice moves cash and receivables, not reported revenue.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending