When a role opens up and the company would like to fill it from its own people, there are two broad ways to do it. The first is the tap on the shoulder: a senior leader or the hiring manager names someone, HR processes the paperwork. The second is internal job posting, usually shortened to IJP: the vacancy is advertised inside the company, any eligible employee can apply, and a selection process follows. I think the second is better for most firms above a certain size, but only with some guardrails. Here is the comparison.

What the tap on the shoulder does well

It is fast. A leader who knows the work and the people can fill a role in days. It is quiet, which matters when the move is sensitive, such as replacing someone who has not yet been told. It suits senior positions where the pool is tiny and everyone already knows everyone. And it puts the decision with the person who will carry the consequences of getting it wrong.

The problems are well known. Leaders nominate people they know, who tend to resemble them or work near them. Talented people in other teams, other cities or other shifts never come into view. Employees conclude that careers depend on visibility, not on performance, and the ones who conclude this first are usually those with options elsewhere. There is a fairness cost to individuals, and a data cost to the company, which has no record of who wanted what.

What open posting does well

It widens the pool and makes the rules visible. Employees see what roles exist, what they require and how to apply. Someone in the Chennai support team can discover a vacancy in analytics in Pune and apply for it. The company retains people who would have left to find that same move externally, saves some agency and advertising spend, and gets a hire who already knows how the organisation works and has an existing performance record.

The costs are real. It creates work for HR and for hiring managers who must interview internal candidates and, importantly, reject most of them with feedback. A rejected internal applicant is still an employee, and a careless rejection can turn into a resignation. It also tends to create friction with the current manager: a good performer applies elsewhere, and the manager hears about it from someone else. And an IJP that is purely ceremonial, with the winner already chosen, destroys trust faster than having no IJP at all.

Guardrails that make open posting work

  • Eligibility rules, published: for example, a minimum period in the current role (often 12 months, though it is the company’s call) and no active performance improvement plan or disciplinary action.
  • A notification norm for the current manager, so the conversation happens openly, ideally before the application reaches the new team. The manager can discuss but not block an eligible application. Some firms allow a short delay for handover but not a veto.
  • The same structured screening and interview used for external candidates. Otherwise the internal route becomes the easy route.
  • Written feedback to every internal candidate who reaches the interview, with a development suggestion.
  • A transition window with a fixed release date, so the old team is not left empty indefinitely.
  • A pay rule for the move: how salary is set when the employee changes grade or function, to avoid the new role paying less or giving a windfall.

The manager-hoarding problem

The strongest argument against IJP is that managers will hide their best people, delaying approvals or discouraging applications. It does happen. The answer is to change what managers are rewarded for. If a manager’s appraisal includes the number of people they developed who moved on to bigger roles, hoarding stops being profitable. If it includes only team output, the manager is behaving rationally. In my view, this is the single most important design choice, more than the portal or the policy wording.

Where I would still tap

Not every role belongs in an open process. Succession for the top few positions is better handled through talent reviews and a planned slate. Short-notice backfills during a crisis may need speed more than process. And confidential restructuring moves cannot be advertised. The honest position is a rule with named exceptions: open posting by default, with the exceptions approved by HR and recorded, so that the exceptions do not slowly swallow the rule.

How to tell if it is working

Track the share of vacancies filled internally, the number of applicants per posting, the proportion of internal applicants from outside the hiring team, and, the number people forget, the retention of internal movers and of rejected applicants a year later. If most postings still go to the manager’s own team members, the process is a formality. If rejected applicants leave at a high rate, the feedback step is failing.

Open posting is slower and noisier than a phone call from a director. What it buys is a company where people believe the next role is available to them, and for retention that belief is worth the noise.

Leave a Reply

Trending