A packaging unit in Vadodara gets a rush order from an export client. The plant normally runs one eight-hour shift. For the next fortnight, the supervisor asks the line workers to stay on for two extra hours a day. Imran, a machine operator, draws ₹24,000 a month as wages, and works six days a week. When the month closes, what should the payroll team pay him for those extra hours, and how do they work it out? Let us follow this one case, because overtime errors almost always appear in the arithmetic, not in the principle.
The principle, stated briefly
Under the Code on Wages, 2019, a worker who works beyond the normal hours fixed for the job is entitled to overtime at not less than twice the normal rate of wages. That “twice” is the floor in the Code itself, and it is a payment for hours actually worked over the limit, not a flat allowance. Working hours themselves are governed by other laws: the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code and state shops and establishments rules, with limits that depend on the type of establishment. So the question “when does overtime start?” is answered by the hours law that applies to you, and “how much is it?” is answered by the wages law.
Step one: find the hourly rate
There is no single formula that every employer follows; what matters is that the method is consistent, lawful and not lower than what the rules require. A common approach for monthly-paid workers is to divide monthly wages by the number of working days, and then by the daily hours. If Imran’s plant counts 26 working days a month and eight hours a day, that is 208 hours a month. ₹24,000 divided by 208 is about ₹115.38 an hour.
Here is the first trap. If payroll uses 30 days instead, the denominator becomes 240 hours, the hourly rate falls to ₹100, and every overtime hour is underpaid by roughly 13%. Which denominator is correct depends on how the wages are defined and how the establishment treats weekly offs. A divisor that treats paid weekly offs as part of the monthly wage is defensible in some settings, but whichever you choose, apply it the same way across all workers and be ready to explain it to an inspector.
Step two: decide which wages count
The rate is based on wages, and the Code defines wages broadly: basic pay, dearness allowance and retaining allowance, with certain items excluded, and a rule that excluded items cannot exceed half of total remuneration (the same 50% principle that shapes salary structures). Imran’s ₹24,000 is assumed here to be fully within wages. In real plants, the rate is often wrongly computed on basic alone, because someone assumed that “overtime is on basic”. That assumption can underpay when allowances forming part of wages are left out. Check the payslip structure before trusting a rate that looks low.
Step three: multiply
Imran works two extra hours on 12 days: 24 hours of overtime. At double the hourly rate of ₹115.38, that is ₹230.77 an hour, so ₹5,538.46 for the fortnight (24 × 230.77). It is paid with that month’s wages or within the time the Code allows for wage payment. Not later “when the order’s payment is received from the client”, which is a surprisingly common practice.
A quick sanity check: Imran’s daily wage on the 26-day basis is about ₹923.08, so two hours at double rate (₹461.54) is half a day’s wage for a quarter of a day’s time. If the supervisor’s rough rule was “two extra hours, pay a quarter of a day”, Imran would be getting only half of what the law requires. Run this kind of check before the payroll file goes out, not after the union representative points it out.
Where it gets messy
- Fractions of an hour. Rules and past practice differ on whether 20 minutes is rounded up. Read the rule applying to your sector and state; do not guess.
- Compensatory time off instead of pay. Time off in lieu feels fair, but it does not by itself satisfy a legal duty to pay for overtime. Do not run it as a substitute unless the law and the worker’s rights allow it.
- Weekly off and holidays. Working on a rest day has its own substitute-day or extra-pay rules, separate from daily overtime.
- Maximum hours. There are ceilings on total daily, weekly and quarterly hours. A plant that pays double but runs workers for 14 hours is still violating the hours law.
Who is outside the picture
Many salaried professionals in IT and services do not receive overtime. That can be legitimate where they fall outside the law’s definition of an employee entitled to it, for example managerial or supervisory roles with real authority, or where state rules for offices and establishments treat them differently. But a job title does not decide this by itself. An “executive” who sits at a counter, takes orders and has no decision power is not automatically exempt because the offer letter says so. Disputes of this type are decided on what the person actually does.
The practical advice for HR is short. Record start and end times honestly, because overtime that is not recorded is overtime that cannot be defended. Fix the divisor in policy. Pay it in the same cycle. And when a rush order arrives, put the cost of double-rate hours into the quotation, because overtime that nobody budgeted for tends to be the first thing a supervisor “adjusts” at month-end.
Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.
Leave a Reply