A common belief in business cases is that if a project “pays back in two years”, that is all a finance team needs. Payback is useful and simple. It is also blind to two things: what happens after the payback date, and when exactly the money arrives. Net present value, NPV, fixes the second problem, and you do not need an MBA to use it.

The idea in one sentence

A rupee today is worth more than a rupee a year from now, because today’s rupee can be invested or can reduce borrowing. So future cash flows are discounted by a rate that reflects the company’s cost of capital or required return. The present value of ₹100 arriving in a year, at a 12 per cent discount rate, is 100 ÷ 1.12, which is about ₹89.3. NPV adds up the discounted inflows and subtracts the upfront cost. A positive NPV means the project earns more than the required return.

Two projects with the same payback

A customer in Guwahati is looking at your automation platform, costing ₹60 lakh upfront. Two possible savings profiles for the four years that follow:

YearProfile A: steady (₹ lakh)Profile B: ramping (₹ lakh)
13010
23020
33035
43055
Total120120

Both total ₹120 lakh. In Profile A, cumulative savings reach ₹60 lakh at the end of year two, so payback is two years. In Profile B, cumulative savings are 10, 30, 65, 120: payback falls during year three, at about 2.9 years. So A already looks better on payback. Now discount at 12 per cent.

Profile A: 30 ÷ 1.12 + 30 ÷ 1.12² + 30 ÷ 1.12³ + 30 ÷ 1.12⁴ comes to about ₹91.1 lakh. Subtract the ₹60 lakh cost and NPV is about ₹31.1 lakh. Profile B comes to about ₹84.7 lakh in present value, so NPV is about ₹24.7 lakh. Same total savings, a gap of over ₹6 lakh, simply because B’s money comes later.

Where each measure misleads

Payback ignores everything after the break-even date. A project that returns the cost in two years and then stops delivering can beat one that returns it in three years and keeps delivering for ten. NPV counts the whole life. On the other side, NPV depends on a discount rate that someone chose, and a small change in it can flip a ranking when benefits are far in the future. Ask the customer’s finance team which rate they use; many companies have a standard hurdle rate and will tell you. Do not invent one.

A third measure, internal rate of return, is the discount rate at which NPV equals zero. It is popular but can mislead when comparing projects of different sizes. For a first business case, NPV and payback together are enough.

Using it with a customer

Do not open with the formula. Build the cash-flow table with the customer, line by line: what they pay and when, what they save and when, who owns each assumption. Then show payback first because everyone understands it, and NPV second as the more careful view. If your product’s benefits come late, because of a long implementation, NPV will show that honestly, and you can show a faster rollout in the plan as a way to improve it.

Be conservative with savings. Finance people trust cost reductions that can be traced to a budget line, and distrust soft benefits like “better productivity”. Include implementation, training and internal time on the cost side. A case that survives a sceptical CFO is worth more than a bigger case that does not.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending