Variable pay comes in two broad forms, and they answer different questions. A short-term incentive asks: how did you and the business do this year? A long-term incentive asks: will the decisions you are making now still look good in three or five years? Most employees see only the first. Senior leaders see both, and the balance between them quietly shapes how they trade off this quarter’s numbers against the company’s future.
Short-term incentives: the annual cycle
A short-term incentive (STI) is usually an annual bonus, sometimes paid half-yearly or quarterly. It is expressed as a target percentage of fixed pay, for example 15% for a manager or 40% for a business head, and the actual payout depends on results measured over the year.
A typical corporate STI combines two layers. A company or business-unit scorecard, built on revenue, operating profit and perhaps customer metrics, determines the size of the overall pool. Individual performance then adjusts each person’s share. The company factor might range from 0% to 150% and the individual factor from 0% to 130%, multiplied together. The design makes everyone care about shared results while still rewarding personal contribution.
STIs have strong “line of sight”: people can see how what they did this year affected what they were paid. That is their strength and their weakness. They reward what is measurable within twelve months, and some valuable work, such as building a capability, investing in a product that pays off later or walking away from a bad contract, does not show up within twelve months.
The Indian statutory bonus under the Code on Wages is a separate thing. It is a legal minimum for employees under a wage threshold and is not a performance incentive, even though both appear in payslips as “bonus”.
Long-term incentives: value over years
A long-term incentive (LTI) pays out over a multi-year horizon, usually three to four years, and is normally linked to the company’s value. The common forms are:
- Stock options (ESOPs): the right to buy shares at a fixed price. Valuable only if the share price rises above that price.
- Restricted stock units (RSUs): shares delivered on vesting with no purchase price. They retain value even if the share price falls, so they are a stronger retention tool and a weaker performance tool.
- Performance share units (PSUs): shares that vest only if specified multi-year goals are met, such as cumulative earnings growth or total shareholder return relative to a peer group. The number vesting can vary, for example from 0% to 200% of target.
- Cash LTIPs: cash bonuses paid after a three-year performance period. Common in unlisted companies, subsidiaries of foreign groups and government enterprises where equity is not available.
Most LTIs are granted every year with overlapping vesting schedules. A leader who has received grants in each of the last four years always has unvested value on the table. Leaving means forfeiting it, which is the retention effect, sometimes called “golden handcuffs”. Hiring such a leader often means the new employer must “buy out” that unvested value with a sign-on grant.
Pay mix by level
How much of total pay sits in each bucket depends on how much a role can influence long-term value. An illustrative CEO package might have ₹1 crore fixed, a target STI of ₹40 lakh and an LTI grant valued at ₹60 lakh. At target, total direct compensation is ₹2 crore, of which only half is fixed, 20% depends on this year and 30% depends on the next several years. A mid-level manager might be 85% fixed, 15% STI, with no LTI at all. An individual contributor engineer in a product company might have no STI but a meaningful RSU grant, because the company wants them to stay and think like an owner, not to chase annual targets.
For listed companies in India, senior management pay is overseen by the board’s Nomination and Remuneration Committee, and SEBI’s listing regulations and the Companies Act shape disclosure and approval. Shareholder advisory firms also comment publicly on pay mix, especially when long-term pay lacks real performance conditions.
Getting the balance wrong
Too much STI. If most of a leader’s variable pay depends on this year’s profit, cutting training, deferring maintenance and squeezing suppliers all look attractive. The costs arrive after the bonus is paid.
LTI without performance conditions. RSUs that vest purely on time reward a leader in a rising market regardless of their contribution, and still reward them partly in a falling one. They retain, but they do not discriminate between good and average leadership.
Overlapping metrics. If the STI pays on annual revenue growth and the PSU pays on three-year revenue growth, the leader is effectively paid twice for the same thing. Better designs use different measures, for example operating profit and cash flow in the STI and relative shareholder return or return on capital in the LTI.
Ignoring the downside. Malus and clawback clauses allow a company to reduce unvested awards or recover paid ones if results are later restated or misconduct comes to light. Regulators have pushed these into banking and financial services in particular; in other sectors they are increasingly common in senior contracts.
A quick way to read any package
Lay out fixed pay, target STI and annual LTI value side by side. Then ask three questions. What has to happen this year for the STI to pay? What has to happen over three or more years for the LTI to be worth its grant value? And what does the person lose by leaving? The answers describe the behaviour the package is buying far more accurately than the total.
Written by the RP Strativa Team. Packages, percentages and ranges in the examples are illustrative.
Leave a Reply