Field notes. Short ones, because this topic does not need dressing up.

A side letter is any promise made to a customer that sits outside the signed contract. An email saying “if you are not happy in six months we will take the licences back.” A WhatsApp message promising free implementation days. A handwritten line on a printed order form. Sometimes a formal-looking letter on company stationery. The form varies. The effect is the same: the contract finance and legal reviewed is no longer the real deal.

My opinion, stated plainly: side letters are almost never worth it, and the people who write them rarely think they are doing anything wrong. That is what makes them dangerous.

How they usually start

Nobody wakes up planning to commit fraud. It is the last week of the quarter. The customer’s procurement head will sign, but wants comfort that they can walk away if the rollout goes badly. Legal at your company will not approve a termination-for-convenience clause. The rep thinks: the customer will never use it, I will just send a reassuring email, and the deal closes today.

The rep has just rewritten the contract without anyone who is paid to notice. The customer now holds a right that nobody inside your company has priced, approved or recorded.

Why finance cares so much

A company recognises revenue based on what the contract actually obliges both sides to do. Under Ind AS 115 (and IFRS 15, which it is aligned with), a contract can be written, oral or implied by customary business practice, and all the terms that create enforceable rights count, not just the ones in the main document. If a customer can return the software, or payment depends on an outcome, or a refund is promised, that changes when and how much revenue can be recognised.

So a side letter that says “you may cancel within six months with a full refund” can mean the sale should not be booked as a firm sale at all. If finance did not know, the books are wrong. If the company is listed, the problem is bigger, because reported numbers feed what investors and regulators rely on. Cases of revenue being overstated through undisclosed side arrangements are a familiar pattern in corporate governance failures, and auditors ask specific questions about them every year.

Many large companies make sales leaders sign a quarterly representation: “I confirm there are no agreements outside the contract.” A rep who signs that while holding a side email has done something much worse than a discount.

The damage reaches further than the books

  • Delivery teams do not know about the promise, so they miss it, and the customer feels cheated.
  • The rep leaves. The promise stays with the customer, who cheerfully produces the email at renewal.
  • Commission has already been paid on a deal that may unwind. Clawing it back is awkward.
  • If the matter reaches court or arbitration, an email from your employee, sent in the course of the deal, can be argued as binding on the company, whatever the “entire agreement” clause says. How far that argument works depends on the facts and the governing law, but you do not want to be testing it.

I have also seen it argued that a side letter is fine if the customer “never uses it”. That is a bet that you know the future. A customer whose project fails will use everything they have.

What to do when the customer asks for comfort

The customer’s worry is usually real. Handle it in the open, in a way that finance and legal can see.

Put it in the contract. If a pilot period or an exit right is genuinely needed, draft it as a clause, get it approved, and let finance decide how to account for it. Often the approved version is narrower than what the rep wanted to give, and that is the whole point of approval.

Offer a different structure. A smaller first purchase, a paid pilot that converts, a staged payment tied to a go-live milestone, or an extended implementation support schedule written into the statement of work. These meet the customer’s anxiety without a secret escape hatch.

Say no, clearly and kindly. “I cannot give you that in writing, and I will not give it to you outside the writing either” is a perfectly professional sentence. Customers with a good procurement team often respect it, because they have their own auditors.

Push the request upward. If a deal needs a nonstandard term, the escalation path exists for exactly that. A deal that cannot survive that path was probably not as ready to close as the forecast claimed.

If you find one

A manager who finds a side email in a rep’s sent folder, or hears about one on a renewal call, should not hide it to protect the quarter. Tell finance and legal quickly. A disclosed side arrangement is fixable: restate the deal, amend the contract, adjust the accounting. A concealed one, found later, becomes a conduct issue for everybody who knew.

Leaders can also reduce the temptation. Stop treating the last-day signature as a heroic act. Reps who know a clean “no” from legal will not cost them their job and a late-quarter slip will not cost them their credibility are far less likely to improvise a promise at 11 pm on the 31st.

One practical control worth having: the order form should include a line stating that it, together with the agreed terms, is the entire agreement, and the customer should be asked to confirm no other commitments were made. It does not stop a determined person, but it makes the honest ones stop and think.

Leave a Reply

Trending