“We need to become more strategic” is probably the most repeated sentence in HR town halls. It is usually followed by a slide with Dave Ulrich’s name on it, a triangle, and the letters HRBP. The belief behind the slide is that strategic HR means moving up, away from payroll and letters and into the boardroom. Let us take that belief apart, along with three others that travel with it.

Belief one: Ulrich designed the HRBP job

Ulrich’s 1997 book Human Resource Champions described four roles the HR function has to play: strategic partner, administrative expert, employee champion and change agent. These are roles, not positions. One person can play several, and the same HR team has to deliver all four. The book was about what HR is accountable for, which in his framing is outcomes the business can see, rather than HR activities.

The structure most people picture, with shared services for transactions, centres of expertise for specialist areas like reward and learning, and business partners facing the business units, was built later by practitioners and consultants on top of those ideas. It is often called the Ulrich model, and Ulrich himself has written on it, but treating the three-part structure as the original theory is a shortcut. Later versions of his own work revised the role list. So when someone says “we are implementing Ulrich”, ask which version, and what problem they hope it will solve.

Belief two: the business partner is a senior generalist who stops doing “HR work”

In practice, a business partner who stops touching people issues is useless. The job is to sit with a business head and turn a business problem into a people question and back again. If a sales director says the new region is not hitting numbers, the partner asks about territory vacancies, the ramp time of new hires, whether incentive plans reward the right behaviour, and whether the managers are any good. Then they bring in the specialists for the answer.

That requires the partner to know the business: how it earns money, which metrics the leader checks on Monday morning. A partner who cannot read a P&L summary will be treated as a messenger. And they do still handle employee relations, performance calibration and exits in their unit. Credibility is built partly by being useful in those messy moments.

Belief three: automate the transactions and HR becomes strategic

A reasonable half-truth. Shared services and self-service portals do free time. But time freed is not the same as time well used. Many HR teams find that once the HRMS handles leave and letters, the same people are still reacting, now to different requests. Strategy needs questions to ask and the standing to ask them; a team that has never presented a view on attrition by tenure will not start merely because it has a spare afternoon.

There is also a cost. A shared services centre that handles payroll queries badly produces angry employees and distrust of HR as a whole. Administrative excellence is not the lesser role; Ulrich’s own list puts “administrative expert” in. If payslips are wrong, nobody will listen to your workforce plan.

Belief four: one model fits every company

A company of 150 people with two HR staff cannot run a three-part structure, because there is nothing to split. A 10,000-person group with ten business lines can, though even there the load on business partners varies. In a mid-sized IT services firm, one partner for a few hundred people in a delivery unit may be workable. In a plant with shifts, contractors and a union, the “partner” often ends up being the industrial relations manager in everything but name.

A fair question is whether the model creates its own problems. Three tiers mean handoffs: the employee asks the portal, the portal sends to the shared service, the shared service escalates to the partner, who asks the centre of expertise. Each handoff is a place where ownership blurs. Some organisations respond by keeping the same names but making one person accountable for the end-to-end experience of a given process.

What is left standing

The durable idea in Ulrich’s work is that HR should be judged by what it delivers for employees, customers and the business, and not by how many programmes it runs. That is a test you can apply in any structure. For instance: if you list the five biggest business problems this year, can you point to what HR did about each?

If you are early in your career and want to be a business partner, the useful preparation is less about frameworks than about learning the business, learning to use data without drowning people in it, and having the nerve to disagree with a senior leader while staying trusted. A model can show you where the chairs are, but it will not make anyone sit in them.

Leave a Reply

Trending