Pull up a chair. You have probably seen the 70-20-10 slide in some training deck: 70 percent of learning comes from doing the job, 20 percent from other people, 10 percent from formal courses. Someone will have said it with great confidence, as though it were a physical constant. Let me tell you what it actually is, because once you understand where it came from, you will use it much better.

Where the numbers came from

The idea is usually traced to research at the Center for Creative Leadership in the United States, associated with Morgan McCall, Michael Lombardo and Robert Eichinger, who asked successful managers to describe the experiences that had shaped them. The answers leaned heavily towards challenging assignments and difficult bosses, and much less towards classrooms. The 70-20-10 split is a rough summary of that tendency, not a measured ratio from a controlled study. Ask a different group and you would get different percentages.

So when someone says “we need to put 70% of our learning budget into on-the-job learning,” they have misread it. It is about where learning happens, not about where money should go. Experience is cheap to provide in rupee terms and expensive in other ways: it costs managers’ time, risk and patience.

The three parts, in plain language

The 70 is experience: doing real work that stretches you. A fresher given a small module to own end to end. A support executive asked to handle escalations for the first time. A team lead taking over a struggling project. You learn because the stakes are real and nobody is going to do it for you.

The 20 is exposure: learning through other people. A senior colleague who reviews your work and tells you plainly what is weak. A mentor outside your team. A manager who thinks aloud about a decision. Pair programming, shadowing a sales call, sitting in on a client review.

The 10 is education: courses, certifications, workshops, e-learning, books. It gives vocabulary and structure, and it is often the quickest way to learn something that is genuinely new, such as a tool, a regulation or a methodology.

What it gets right

The strongest point, in my view, is the warning against believing that sending people on a course is the same as developing them. Many a company has paid for a two-day leadership workshop, watched managers return and behave exactly as before, and concluded that “training does not work”. The workshop was never going to do it alone. Without a chance to try the new skill on real work, with someone giving feedback, little of it sticks.

It is also a good prompt for managers. If most growth happens on the job, then who gets the stretch assignments is a development decision. In many teams, the interesting work quietly goes to the same two people, and everyone else wonders why they are not growing. That is a real and fixable problem.

Where it misleads

First, the proportions. There is no good evidence that the right mix is exactly 70-20-10 for everyone. A new chartered accountant learning a changed tax rule needs mostly formal input. A fresher learning to code needs a lot of structured teaching before experience is useful, and throwing them into production work with no foundation is not stretching, it is sinking.

Second, “learning on the job” can be a polite way of saying “no support”. If the experience is not chosen, reviewed and discussed, people simply repeat the same year ten times. Twenty years of experience can be one year of learning, repeated.

Third, it is awkward to measure. Nobody can honestly tell you what percentage of last year’s learning came from which source. Be wary of any dashboard that claims to.

Using it as a conversation, not a rule

Here is how I would use it with a manager. Take one person you want to grow. Ask three questions. What real task could I give them in the next quarter that is slightly beyond what they can do today? Who could they learn from, and have I made that happen, or hoped it would? And is there a specific piece of knowledge they lack that a short course would give them faster than trial and error?

Notice that the answer does not come to 70, 20 and 10. It comes to a plan: one assignment, one person and perhaps one course. Write it in the development section of the appraisal, with a review date. That will do more than any amount of arguing over percentages.

If you run learning for a company, the useful shift is in where you spend your attention. Spend less time polishing the catalogue of courses and more on helping managers set up stretch work and feedback. A great course catalogue with a poor manager habit changes very little. A modest catalogue with managers who give people interesting work and talk to them about it changes a lot.

Leave a Reply

Trending