Meera runs inside sales for an invented HR-software company in Pune. On 3 August she moves a ₹40 lakh opportunity, a mid-sized manufacturer’s payroll and attendance rollout, to Stage 4: proposal submitted, pricing discussed. In her company’s CRM, Stage 4 carries a 60% probability. The deal is now worth ₹24 lakh in the weighted pipeline.

On 3 November, the deal is still in Stage 4. Nothing has been lost. The buyer replies politely when chased. “Management is reviewing.” “Finance has a few questions.” The forecast still counts ₹24 lakh. The question this article is about is simple: should it?

Stage probability ignores the clock

A stage probability is an average across all deals that reach that stage. The 60% says that, historically, six in ten deals that got to a proposal went on to close. It says nothing about how long they took, and that is the trouble. A deal that has been in a stage for three days and one that has been there for ninety share the same percentage in most CRMs, though they are plainly not the same animal.

Deals that progress tend to move. Somebody asks for a reference call, a security questionnaire arrives, legal sends comments. Silence is also a signal, and it is usually a bad one. This is the idea behind pipeline ageing: measure days in current stage, compare against what normal looks like for your own history, and adjust.

Building your own yardstick

Pull the deals Meera’s company won in the last two years and note how long each spent in Stage 4. Suppose, illustratively, the median is 18 days, and nearly all won deals left the stage within 45. Now take the deals that reached Stage 4 and were eventually lost or abandoned. Many of those sat there far longer, because nobody wanted to close them out.

With that, a simple rule appears. Under 18 days: normal. Between 18 and 45: watch it. Beyond 45, which is 2.5 times the median: the 60% no longer applies to this deal. Perhaps the company’s data says deals past that mark closed one time in seven, about 14%. Then Meera’s ₹40 lakh is worth roughly ₹5.7 lakh in expectation, not ₹24 lakh. Check: 40 × 1/7 = 5.71.

The gap between ₹24 lakh and ₹5.7 lakh is ₹18.3 lakh, from one deal. A pipeline with twenty such deals produces a forecast that is wrong by crores, and no one has done anything dishonest. Each rep simply left a deal where it was.

Why deals stall

Back to Meera. When she looks honestly at the account, the pattern is familiar. Her only contact is the HR manager, who likes the product. The CFO has never been in a meeting. There is no date on which the manufacturer needs the system running. And the proposal went out as a PDF, so she does not know who has read it.

Those are four distinct causes, and a stalled deal usually has one of them:

  • No economic buyer involved, so nobody with the authority to spend is engaged.
  • No compelling event, so waiting costs the buyer nothing.
  • A better priority has appeared inside the buyer’s company and your project lost the queue.
  • A competitor, or the existing way of working, is quietly winning.

Each calls for a different move. Chasing with “any update?” fixes none of them.

What Meera does on 4 November

She asks her manager to send a short note to the manufacturer’s managing director, not about price but about timing: what would need to be true for a decision before the end of the financial year? She asks the HR manager, plainly, who else needs to say yes and whether she can join one conversation with them. She proposes a dated next step to both: a 30-minute call on a named day with a named agenda.

And inside her own CRM she does the awkward part. She moves the close date from the end of November to a realistic one, or she moves the deal back a stage, or she closes it as lost with the reason “no decision”. Each option is better than leaving it. A deal that is honestly small in the forecast can still win and become a pleasant surprise. A deal that is falsely large in the forecast can only disappoint.

Rules that managers can apply without drama

A few that tend to work, though the thresholds should come from your own data and not from this article. Show “days in stage” next to every opportunity in the weekly review. Flag anything beyond twice the median. Require a dated next step with a customer name in every open deal; no date, no commit. Review the oldest ten deals each month and either re-qualify or close them. And when someone closes a stale deal as lost, treat that as good hygiene, not as bad news.

One honest caveat: some industries have long, slow decisions by nature, such as government and large manufacturing groups with committee approvals. There the median itself is long and the yardstick must come from similar deals, not from a faster segment. Ageing only tells you something when compared with the right peers.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending