A senior developer with five years at your company earns ₹14 lakh. Last month, the company hired someone with a similar background at ₹16.5 lakh because that is what the market asked for. Somehow, within a week, everyone on the team knows. This is pay compression, sometimes called salary inversion when it flips the order entirely. It has two broad responses, and the choice between them says a great deal about a company.

How it happens

The cause is arithmetic. Annual increments run at, say, 8 to 10 percent, while the price of hiring for a hot skill can jump 25 percent in a year. Each year, existing employees move up slowly while the entry point to the market runs ahead. After three or four years the gap is large. It is worst in fields where demand moves fast, such as cloud, data and AI, and in companies that give modest increments for strong years and give no mid-year corrections.

Compa-ratio is the quickest way to see it. Plot every employee in a grade against the band midpoint. Compression shows as long-serving people clustered at 0.85 or 0.9, and recent joiners at 1.05 or more.

Approach one: hold the line

The first approach says: pay is set by the market at the time of hiring, increments reward performance, and we do not reopen salaries because a new person was expensive. Defenders have a point. Every adjustment sets a precedent, the budget is finite, and if you correct for every market blip you will pay for the same increase twice. There is also a fairness argument against rewarding people for the noise of the hiring market.

Where this works, it works because the company is honest about it, existing staff have clear promotion paths, and increments are generous enough that the gap closes in a cycle or two. Where it fails, it fails slowly and expensively. The long-serving employee who finds out their pay is lower does not complain. They update their CV. You then replace them with another market-priced hire, and the gap you refused to close has cost you more than closing it would have.

Approach two: correct existing pay

The second approach reviews pay for existing staff against the market and adjusts where the gap is large and the person matters. The cost is visible. If 40 employees average ₹1.5 lakh below the level where they should sit, closing the gap fully costs 40 times 1.5 lakh, which is ₹60 lakh a year, plus statutory contributions linked to pay. That is not small, and it will not fit in an ordinary increment budget.

The benefit is the avoided loss. A common estimate of the cost of replacing a skilled employee runs to a large fraction of annual pay once recruitment, ramp-up and lost output are counted. If correcting pay prevents even a handful of exits among valuable people, the sum begins to look reasonable. The risk is the other way round: the company corrects those who are loud or visible, and those who are quiet are left behind, which creates a new unfairness.

Which I would choose

My view is that holding the line as a policy is rarely defensible when the gap is large and the people are performing well, and that blanket correction is rarely affordable. The sensible position sits between them, with rules that you can explain.

  1. Review compa-ratios by grade and role every year, not only when someone complains.
  2. Set a ceiling on how far a new hire can be placed above existing peers without a documented reason. The offer committee should see the internal comparison before approving, not afterwards.
  3. Keep a separate correction budget, apart from the performance increment pool. Otherwise corrections eat into the raises of high performers.
  4. Prioritise by performance, criticality and the size of the gap. Close the largest gaps for the strongest people first, over two cycles if needed.
  5. Tell people the principle, even if not the numbers. “We review pay against the market each year and correct where the gap is material” is something a manager can say honestly.

Be careful about the confidentiality angle. Few Indian employers publish salaries, and many make disclosure a policy matter. That makes it harder for employees to learn the truth, but not impossible, and you should assume they will. Plan as though every salary will be known.

There are also cases where the right answer is to leave a difference alone: a new hire with a rare skill and genuine extra scope, hired for a role that is truly a grade higher. The test is whether you can explain the difference in terms of the work, in a way the veteran would accept. If the only honest explanation is “the market made us”, then it is compression, and it needs managing.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending