Imagine a mid-sized auto-component maker with a plant near Hosur. A new line of automated machines has made one older assembly section largely redundant, and management has to bring about 120 positions down to about 70 over the next year. Layoffs make leadership uneasy, because the workforce is long-serving and the union is active. So someone proposes a voluntary retirement scheme, or VRS. Let us follow that one decision, because the concept shows itself best in a particular place.
What a VRS actually is
A VRS is an offer, not an order. The company announces a window, usually a few weeks, during which eligible employees may choose to leave in return for a package better than normal separation terms. Eligibility is typically by age or length of service, say 40 and above or 10 years of service. A voluntary separation scheme (VSS) is the same idea without the age condition, so younger employees can opt in too. Nobody is forced; if too few apply, the company has not met its target and has to consider other routes.
The legal significance is that a genuinely voluntary exit is not a retrenchment. Industrial law treats retrenchment as termination by the employer for any reason, with defined exceptions, and voluntary retirement is among those exceptions. That is why the word “voluntary” has to be true in practice. If employees are told they will be dismissed anyway and this is the kinder option, a dispute about voluntariness becomes likely.
Pricing the offer
There is no statutory formula for the package; companies design it. A common shape is some number of days of pay for each completed year of service, sometimes plus a share of the months remaining until retirement, on top of the dues the person would get anyway: gratuity, leave encashment, provident fund.
Work one case, with invented numbers. A machine operator aged 48 has 15 years’ service and monthly pay (basic plus allowances counted for the scheme) of ₹80,000. The scheme offers 45 days per completed year. That is 15 x 45 = 675 days, or 22.5 months at 30 days a month, which comes to ₹18,00,000. Add three months’ pay in lieu of notice, ₹2,40,000, and the ex-gratia package is ₹20,40,000 before gratuity and encashment.
Now the saving. Suppose the all-in annual cost of that employee, including employer contributions and bonus, is about 20 percent above pay: ₹9,60,000 x 1.2 = ₹11,52,000. Payback is 20,40,000 / 11,52,000, which is roughly 1.8 years. Management will find that acceptable. If the payback were five years, it would be a poor use of money, and the number is worth calculating before the scheme is announced, not afterwards.
The adverse selection problem
Here is where the Hosur story turns. Suppose 70 people apply, but the best 30 CNC programmers are among them, because they know they will find work elsewhere in a week. The ones who stay are, on average, those with fewer options. Economists call this adverse selection, and it is the standard weakness of voluntary schemes: the people most willing to leave are often the ones the company most wanted to keep.
Companies handle this by reserving the right to accept or reject each application. The announcement says so, and the criteria are stated in advance: critical skills, safety certifications, pending handovers. Rejecting someone who has already mentally left is uncomfortable, so the message must be handled carefully and early, not in the last week.
The mechanics, in order
- Decide the target, the budget and the maximum payback before talking to anyone.
- Brief the union or employee representatives. In a unionised plant, a scheme nobody consulted tends to be treated as an attack.
- Publish terms in writing: eligibility, formula, window, the company’s right to decline, payment date, and what happens to benefits such as medical cover.
- Offer individual counselling, with a sample calculation for each person, so they see numbers for their own case.
- Allow a short cooling-off period in which the application can be withdrawn, if the terms say so.
- Get a signed acceptance and a release at settlement, then pay on the date promised.
Tax and the fine print
The income tax treatment of VRS compensation is a point employees care about intensely. Historically, an exemption has been available for compensation paid under an approved scheme, subject to a ceiling (₹5 lakh in the older provisions) and to conditions such as the scheme following prescribed guidelines and the employee not being re-employed in the same industry. Section numbers and wording have changed with the new Income-tax Act, so check the current provisions and have the scheme reviewed by your tax adviser before launch. Anything above the exempt portion is taxed as salary, though relief on retirement compensation may apply. Do not promise a tax outcome in the announcement.
A few other points apply whatever the numbers are. Government and public sector bodies run VRS under their own rules, which differ from private employers. A second scheme offered a year later teaches employees to wait for a better one, so the first must be priced to be believed. And the people who remain need attention: survivors of a drawdown often carry extra work and anxiety, so tell them clearly what the new structure is.
Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.
Leave a Reply