Here is a small puzzle for your first week in an HR team. Your company has an office in Bengaluru, another in Pune and a small sales branch in Kolkata. The leave policy says 12 casual leaves, the holiday list has 10 days, and the working week is Monday to Friday. A new joiner in Kolkata asks why her paid leave seems different from her friend’s in Pune. You check, and find that your single “India policy” is quietly breaking a rule in one of the three states. How?
The answer is the Shops and Establishments Act. Settle in; it is less boring than it sounds.
There is not one Act, there are many
Labour is on the Concurrent List in the Constitution, but shops and commercial establishments are regulated by state legislation. So there is a Karnataka Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, a Maharashtra Shops and Establishments (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, a Delhi Shops and Establishments Act, a Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishments Act, and so on. They share a family resemblance but differ in details, sometimes in important ones.
Whose employees fall under it? Broadly, anyone working in a shop, commercial establishment, office, restaurant, hotel or place of entertainment, which means your software company, consulting firm, bank branch or BPO site is included, even though you never sell a bag of rice. Factories, in contrast, are covered by the Factories Act (and now the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020, where in force). A company with a factory and a head office will find both regimes apply, to different premises.
What it usually regulates
Think of it as the basic working conditions statute for non-factory work. The common subjects:
- Registration of the establishment with the state labour department, or in some states an intimation, often depending on how many people you employ.
- Daily and weekly hours, with a cap and rules for overtime and for rest intervals.
- A weekly day off.
- Paid holidays, including national and festival days.
- Annual, sick and casual leave entitlements, in some states.
- Conditions for women working at night, and for young persons.
- Rules on termination and notice for certain categories, and registers and notices to be maintained.
I am deliberately not giving you one set of numbers. Daily limits are commonly in the range of eight to ten hours, with overall weekly caps around forty-eight hours, and overtime limits per quarter, but they differ by state and have been amended repeatedly. Karnataka, for instance, has seen its rules for overtime and working hours changed more than once by amendment; check the current text. The habit that matters is checking the Act and rules for the state where each employee works, and re-checking annually.
Back to the Kolkata puzzle
Your policy gives 12 casual leaves in all locations. Perhaps the state law provides paid leave of a certain number of days after a stated period of service, and your policy counts it differently. Or the state’s holiday notice requires specific festival days that your company list drops. Neither is a disaster, but they illustrate how a uniform national policy can fall below a state minimum without anyone noticing.
The fix is not to write twenty-eight policies. Draft one national policy built on the more generous end, then add a short state annexure for the places where the law demands something specific. In HR parlance: set the floor by law, the standard by company choice.
Does the IT office get special treatment?
Several states have granted IT and IT-enabled services establishments partial exemptions from provisions, such as those on working hours or on night work, usually through notifications that come with conditions and expiry dates. Do not assume the exemption is still running, covers your kind of company, or comes without conditions like transport for women employees. Look for the notification, read its conditions, and keep a copy in the compliance file.
Compliance tasks, in a sensible order
When you set up a new branch, a rough order that works:
- Register or intimate within the time the state allows, and display the certificate.
- Read the state’s current rules for hours, weekly off and holidays, and put the state’s holiday list in place.
- Open the registers or electronic equivalents the rules require, covering attendance, wages and leave.
- Renew registrations on time; many states need periodic renewal or fee payment.
- Calendar the notifications that expire.
Penalties under these Acts are mostly modest fines per offence, which tempts small companies to ignore them. A bad idea: the labour department inspector who turns up for a fine often ends up asking about minimum wages, PF and POSH too, and an unregistered establishment has no friends in that conversation.
How it fits with the Labour Codes
The OSH Code brings several central laws together, and one might expect it to swallow the state shops laws as well. Its treatment of establishments overlaps with their subject, but states still have their own Acts in force, and what replaces or coexists with them is being worked out through rules and notifications. Until your state says otherwise in writing, treat the existing Act as the one that applies, and watch the labour department’s website for updates.
Small law, big reach. It is the reason a “pan-India policy” almost always needs a state page behind it.
Leave a Reply