Imagine a software company in Indore, call it Sahyadri Systems, selling a plant-maintenance product for many years. Customers buy a perpetual licence for ₹1 crore, install it on their own servers, and then pay an annual maintenance contract of about 20 per cent of the licence price. The company signs ten new customers a year. Results are predictable, the bank is happy, and the CEO decides to move to a subscription cloud product at ₹30 lakh a year per customer. Customers like it. It is cheaper to start, easier to run, and upgrades arrive automatically.

Then the board meeting happens, and the numbers look as if the company is shrinking. Let us work out why.

Two models, same ten customers a year

Under the old model, a licence is typically recognised as revenue when the customer receives the right to use the software, essentially upfront (the accounting treatment under Ind AS 115 depends on the specifics of the contract, so this is a simplification). Maintenance is recognised over time. In year one, ten customers give ₹10 crore. In year two, ten new licences give another ₹10 crore, plus maintenance from the first cohort, 10 × ₹20 lakh = ₹2 crore, so ₹12 crore. Year three: ₹10 crore plus ₹4 crore maintenance, so ₹14 crore. Each year adds ₹2 crore to the previous one.

Under the new model, a subscription is recognised evenly across the term. Year one: ten customers at ₹30 lakh is ₹3 crore. Year two: twenty customers, ₹6 crore. Year three: thirty, ₹9 crore. Each year adds ₹3 crore.

The dip and the crossover

Put them side by side. In year one the old model reports ₹10 crore and the new one ₹3 crore. By year five it is ₹18 crore against ₹15 crore. The annual figures cross at year eight, where both show ₹24 crore. But the company has been paid and has recognised less all the while, so the running total is what hurts: cumulative revenue under the old model is ₹360 crore at year fifteen, and only then does the subscription model catch up to the same ₹360 crore. After that, it pulls ahead.

The assumptions matter. I assumed no churn, constant ten new customers a year, and maintenance that never lapses. In real life, some on-premise customers stop paying maintenance and some subscribers leave, so the true crossover differs. What does not change is the shape: a sharp fall in near-term revenue followed by a long, steady climb.

Cash makes it worse, or better

Licences are usually paid early. Subscriptions may be billed annually in advance, which helps cash, but a ₹30 lakh payment is still far less than ₹1 crore. So the company has to fund the same salaries and servers on a smaller inflow while the base builds. A transition that is not financed, through reserves or investment, can run a healthy company out of money. That is the plain reason many established vendors drag the change out for years, or run both models together.

What it does to the sales team

A rep paid commission on first-year licence value suddenly sells a deal worth under a third of the previous one. If the plan does not change, the best reps leave or keep selling the old product. Companies usually move to quotas based on annual recurring revenue, sometimes with transitional guarantees. Measures change as well: bookings, ARR and renewal rate replace licence revenue as the headline numbers. Investors have to be told why reported growth is lower, and that is why many companies publish ARR next to the accounting figures.

Existing customers also need a path. Do you force them to migrate? Discount the conversion? Keep supporting the old version at a rising price? Each answer affects revenue, and none is free.

Was it worth it?

Usually the argument is not about the arithmetic but about the market. If customers are going to demand cloud delivery anyway, staying on perpetual licences means losing them gradually, which has its own curve. The people who run these transitions successfully tend to be those who explained the dip to the board in advance, with a model like the one above, instead of presenting it as a surprise.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending