A BPO can organise itself in two broad ways. The horizontal generalist sells a function, such as voice customer support or data entry, to anyone who needs it: a bank on Monday, a travel firm on Tuesday, an e-commerce platform on Wednesday. The vertical specialist picks an industry, say insurance or healthcare or logistics, and offers many functions inside it: claims, underwriting support, customer service, collections. Both exist at every size. My argument is that for most mid-sized firms, the vertical route is the better bet, though it is not free of cost.

What the generalist has going for it

Start with the fair case. A horizontal firm has a very large market to sell into. Its delivery engine, meaning recruitment, training, workforce management and quality, is reusable across clients, so it can get good at running seats efficiently. Because its clients sit in different industries, a downturn in one does not necessarily hurt the rest: when travel collapsed in 2020, a firm with retail and telecom clients was cushioned in a way a pure travel specialist was not. And it can say yes quickly to almost any enquiry.

These are real advantages, particularly for the large players that run tens of thousands of seats and compete on scale, price and global footprint.

Where the generalist struggles

The trouble is that generic delivery looks the same from outside. When ten bidders offer comparable voice support, the buyer’s main lever is price, and margins get squeezed. Seat-based work is also the first to be hit by automation and AI: the more routine and domain-light the work, the easier it is for the client to replace or to rebid.

There is also a depth problem. A client with a complicated product, such as a health insurer with rules on claims adjudication, does not want to teach every agent from zero. The generalist has to spend time and money building that knowledge for each new client in a given industry, and takes the knowledge away when the contract ends.

What the specialist has going for it

Domain depth is a form of difference that clients will pay for. An insurance-focused BPO that already employs people who understand policy lifecycle, regulatory reporting and fraud patterns can start work faster, make fewer errors, and talk to the client’s own experts as peers. That shows up as better quality, shorter ramp-up, and often a move from per-seat pricing towards per-transaction or outcome-linked pricing, because the specialist can credibly take on responsibility for results.

Specialism also compounds. Each engagement adds templates, reusable analytics, automation for common processes, and case references in the same industry. A prospect in that industry sees that the firm has already solved a similar problem, which shortens the sales cycle. And talent follows: people with domain skills build careers there, which helps retention in specialised roles.

The specialist’s real risks

Concentration is the honest cost. If 70% of revenue comes from one industry, a regulation change or a downturn there hits the whole firm. The specialist may also hit a ceiling: there are only so many clients in a niche, and the largest of them may build their own captive centres or prefer a big integrator. And specialism requires investment ahead of revenue, such as hiring subject experts and obtaining certifications, with no guarantee the market will pay.

The mitigation is to specialise in more than one vertical but not in all of them, perhaps two or three, chosen because they share capabilities. Healthcare and insurance share regulatory data handling and claims logic, for instance. Choosing adjacent verticals lets reuse happen across them while cutting the single-industry risk.

Taking a side

If you are a giant with scale economics, being horizontal is rational, though even giants increasingly organise sales and delivery by industry. If you are mid-sized, trying to be everything to everyone leaves you competing on price with firms that have lower costs than you. In that position I would choose two or three verticals, accept the concentration risk consciously, and spend heavily on depth.

A reasonable test for any firm: take your last five contract wins and ask why the client chose you. If the answer is “competitive price”, you are a horizontal commodity, whatever your brochure says. If the answer is “they understand our business”, you have the beginnings of a vertical position, and the strategy question is whether to deepen it deliberately.

One more caution. Specialism is not a label. Renaming a team “BFSI practice” without domain hires, process content and measurable results is branding only, and sophisticated clients can tell within one meeting.

Leave a Reply

Trending