Notes for operations managers. Short version: the team leader with the highest attrition is sometimes the problem and sometimes not, and the ranking alone cannot tell you which. I have seen managers act on the ranking. I think that is lazy, and it often fixes the wrong thing.

Start with the denominator

Monthly attrition is exits divided by average headcount. Now look at team size. Suppose Meera leads a team that averages 12 agents and two leave this month. That is 2 / 12, or 16.7%. Arun leads 40 agents and two leave too. That is 5%. Same number of exits, a threefold difference in the rate. Put both on a league table and Meera looks like a crisis.

With small teams, one resignation swings the percentage hugely. Do not rank on a single month. Use a rolling three or six months, or look at exits per 100 agent-months. If Meera’s team shows 17% in month one and 0% in months two and three, you have a blip. If it shows 14%, 17% and 10%, you have a pattern.

Ask who left

Not all exits are equal. Split them. Did they leave in the first 90 days or after two years? Were they top performers or on a performance plan? Voluntary or terminated? A team leader who exits poor performers promptly may show high “attrition” and be doing the right thing. A team leader whose best agents leave is losing something real.

Early exits deserve a separate look because they often have nothing to do with the team leader. If new batches are placed on that team because it has seats, or because the team has the harder queue, or the night shift, the team is inheriting the risk. Check the allocation before the person.

Compare like with like

Teams differ in shift, queue complexity, tenure mix and even commute. A team on a late rotating shift in a city where transport is hard will lose people regardless of leadership. Compare each team with others on the same shift and queue, or compare a team against its own history. A team whose attrition doubled after a change of leader is more informative than a team that has always been high.

What the leader does matters, so look for it

Having ruled out the artefacts, you may still find a real pattern. My opinion is that team leaders influence attrition mostly through four things, none mysterious: how fairly they handle schedules and leave, how they give feedback (privately, specifically, not only when numbers drop), whether they back their agents in front of customers and management, and whether people see any path forward. When agents say “I am leaving because of my TL”, they usually mean one of these.

How to find out: read exit interviews, but treat them with caution, because people avoid burning bridges. Better data comes from stay interviews with those still there, short skip-level conversations, and the pulse survey if the company runs one. Also watch the quieter signals: unplanned leave, adherence and sudden dips in individual performance often move weeks before a resignation.

Then act, in proportion

If the evidence points at the leader, start with coaching and a specific plan, not a threat. Pair the leader with a stronger peer, sit in on a few huddles and one-on-ones, and agree two or three behaviours to change with a date to review. Many first-time team leaders were promoted for being good agents and were never taught how to lead. That is a training gap, and it can be closed.

If the problem persists despite support, a move to a role without direct reports is a fair outcome, and better than leaving a team to absorb the cost. Be honest with the team about what is changing, without airing the details.

If the evidence points elsewhere, fix that instead: rebalance the allocation of new hires, review the incentive, repair the shift pattern. Telling a team leader “this is not on you” when it is not is also part of the job, and it builds trust that pays back later.

One check on yourself

Ask whether you are measuring attrition because it is easy to count or because it is the real signal. A team with zero attrition can also be a bad sign: people who are stuck, with nowhere else to go, are not necessarily engaged. Attrition is a symptom. Treat it as a question to investigate, not a verdict to deliver.

Figures and names in the examples are illustrative.

Leave a Reply

Trending